You know right now. Yesterday. Every day about another one of these areas that I keep reading. I'm telling you it sort of fell over the you know this already got more than a hundred people here only thank you Jennifer for Doc and also for making the arrangements and now with her first courteous and as you're CARNEY I assume that you're the educator aware about what you know about protein Monica and other areas but just in case you're very brief introduction about proteins so. So there are many ways of approaching this and a simple way to look at a protein protein Monica is a part of your chain and you can view it as prose. So the purse Cami in twenty different colors representing the twenty of I mean I C's. So this is technically referred to what the quote of the backbone and then the pros with different cars are the side chains and this represented a that I mean I sees when a protein is a sized. Typical media phone into a defined structure and in this processors the physical properties of the of the side seams come into play. So in particular on the. And I. Side chains stand have a positive charge when negative charges and the side change that are what's referred to as a non-polar and this is different physical properties are you saying shill for the structure formation when approaching folds. So the non-polar residues side chains. Tend not to like water so when the protein follows those slides genes are then buried in the protein cheerier whereas the target residues direct with the water so they typically s'posed on the surface and if they charge a side teens sometimes can a range of such dead the interactive favorably with each other. Positive with a negative charge other times they actually have you can have a concentration of charges and they saw will be important one. Proteins way you interact with each other so you would have a positive charge of the protein directing ways which are the protein for example and this will come into play you some of the processes that I would be describing so. So that this discharges will play an important role in the interactions. So by now we know that proteins function not an isolated isolation but rather protein monikers already very social beasts they form. Complex and work together and so protein Association the processors of proteins coming together to form complexes is a really key step function you know of that underlie most Bon article process sees so I want to highlight it with just one of those processes in the process so. Approaching things is seize the senses. Proteins itself and you may know that this process happens through a big complex. Consists of a protein monic used in our name on it. Use called the right. So all the players including the messenger. This is where the genetic information is a coded and then trends are in a scene new I mean I see these and then these are stitched together to form a new approach. So this is a highly simplified view of protein things that you may think this is already complex complicated not but if this is already kind of complicated simplify it a little or. Reduced to conversion has as many players. I don't mean to go through this. So it goes through this whole. Different cycles that can take would take the whole next year. So rather than that I'm just going to give you the impression that this is a process that involves a lot of association disassociation many different factors that are involved and the. Properties of this association stamps. Then I use a show for controlling the accuracy and efficiency of the censuses processors so. So this is the point that protein Association rates in America needs and are essential for Under this is understood in this particular one article process but also for understanding. When I can recognition the biological processes in general I also. Already mention about rates this is. The speed at which proteins as associate is measured is measured by the social rate constants and. The magnetism based on refers to the a a mechanical description of the association curse. So this is a problem that. We have been studying for for for quite some time. So the focus is on the association rate. Again the this is the speed at which protein Association a curse and is associated rates different proteins span a very wide range over ten the water is orders of magnitude and the rate constants is mad in this funny unit quote promotion or percent and this is the bottom one I can oppressors. So their concentration is involved. That's why the promotion or course is there so they were approaching associate at a rate rate constant the high incidence of pence Pomona per se. Again and then there are also proteins that associate at around the ONE COME ON percent in the lower. So the span as I said ten orders of magnitude and the message I want to. A convey to you is that we've made significant progress we think that there will be unable to do calculations for about half of the spectrum so raise that a higher than from the end of the first Come on her second we can have a pretty good a hen dong you making calculations. So that's basically the the story I want to tell you and I'm on the way I was so long before the grad student audience that make the pointed at you. Will you will see that one course is that your to have taken while taking will come into play. So how about we were ready then I mean to play quantum mechanics to play where you know Meghan coming to play and the worst is just a mechanics come into play. So all those clues are used in our in our research. So how do we define the social. Rate comes in and so this basically describes the process in which two protein molecules come together to form a complex. So those typically when you're all involved in these two steps. So the first step is the coming together and if uprooting monic use this is a processors this process is essentially a. Diffusion of step. So basically proteins move together. They swim together by. Diffusion. And then once they are nearly shot there. Then there will also have to make adjustments. So that they form any specific complexes in other words the structure of the complex is such that it's always one portion of one protein come into contact with another portion of a second approach you need to always the same contact at a form where you when protein is. The comeback that would form the same complex. So so it's specific so to model this processors we can use different laugh always of descriptions. So the simpler the model is the one which would represent each protein as if it's a circle particle and this what it describes where the first step the diffusion of step. So we're basically described this pair of monic used and the function that we use for here is what's called the pear dispersion function this is basically it's a function that depends on the separation of the two spherical particles and it's also a function of time me to measures the relative TO should be the city of despair as a function of distance between then and this is basically described a by diffusion equation. Except. It's also could be influenced by interactions between. True proteins so the made one protein may be positive charge the other protein may be negative charge and so they attract each other and then combine the fusion that's what this. This is both my factor and need and it's reciprocal for. So this space and model of the buyers over the Internet can paint you to the. Binding processors and so that diffusion you question is very similar to this equation so this is you can basically see this is real time a shred into creation and you can't any trends of this equation actually into a division equation by by. Transmission word you relate you to a different function so basically this becomes a try to equation with a transformed potential. So if you will solve the diffusion equation and then the rate constant. Is then deter me to buy the phlox of the pair distribute function and calculate it at the end of the context surface and. And since this is a partial difference equation then we need to specify the initial condition the user can he simply the Bozeman should be able. And then the boundary condition then there are there is out up on the can and that's when that is a very far part. That's basically it's. Simply that the value of that if you hear from one it's a reference and then that you know about a condition mottos the. Their reaction this is basically when. When the moderators have to make make arrangements to form the complex and then you can modify that as they say you know boundary foundation So for example the simpler the kind of Obama inclination would be absorbing going to condition which mottoes the case were to. Proteins form a complex as soon as they touch each other and. You can also use absorbing Barnett and that would model the case where you actually have to wait for a while for them to form a complex In other words they don't form a complex. Every time when they see each other. So that's that's that mathematical problem and. For the simple condom ato So whereas protein monikers in our study not spheres. So the problem can still be described in the same framework. So instead of just modern in the nation at the fusion Now if a calm before the shape of the proteins we have to then worry about rotation of diffusion as well. So instead of. Only street space then now we have sixteen years from three fortunes in Asian history for diffusion so fundamental Magic's is still the same. It's just a slow motion becomes more difficult. So there are a few model systems a word this problem in connection to solve and economy and one that's simplest is one which I just described as soon as the two proteins see each other and they form a complex and this is the problem there is solved about one hundred years ago that by. And he was not certain not worrying about Association of proteins rather he was worried about the coordination of the Calo oysters and the colorful Kahlo is. The cognition happens nonspecific and so. So this is a reasonable model. And then. Some years later. Peter did by solving the problem. Were. You have interactions between the two particles. So for example one would carry a positive charge. There will carry and negative charge and they say again the diffusion problem can be solved and. And this is the association rate constant to get closer to prove you weren't you need to worry about the specificity of the complex form. So a more realistic model will be one that Barry carries a patch. So that you assume that the complex form. Only when the true patches are in contact with each other and this is a problem. This also been solved. So I solved the. Good by version of this model were you have interactions between the two patched queues and this solving this problem is it's very similar to solving the I'm going to momentum problem in quantum mechanics and so you see just this C L L one or two of these. Clamps cord and coefficients. So it's the same problem that you solve to get the you need to go results. Now these solutions are complicated but nevertheless they are limited to use in the sense that that approach not. And we need to worry about the details shapes of a protein molecules and for that. I don't think you will be ever be able to find and a and in due course in the oceans. So we have to then resort to some in Asians in this kind of some nations that we do. Is referred to as a Brownian dynamics minae sions you're right right. But as long as you're. Stay with the simple John the trees. I mean there are there are solutions but we want to move away from the simple geometry is and work which is the actual shapes of protein mining cues and so as I said we do brawn and I'm examinations by that basically if the fusion of the true party goes and we we base the front of the random motion of the monic use in trends in Asia and in rotation. And then. From the summit nations then we'll get the rate constant so for that we need an average. So from the simulations that we so that we can we can get the rate constant So there is. A algorithm and it's developed by and I'm a chemist group in the one nine hundred eighty S.. Just very briefly so what they did was they start to fix one protein Monica in the in the center and then start the other proto monic you on a circle surface and then for each trajectory just started a final. Until it either reaches the binding site that's when you terminate the trajectory or you to riches a surface. Been absorbed there. And so for you Are you basically. Required was that one of these final fate whether or not it's absorbed at the binding site was absorbed by the. Outer surface. And Kalkin and. This this. This kept your probe in eighty that it's a fraction of a trajectory that I actually captured about the by an inside as opposed to reaching the outer surface and from that you can get the rate constant So there are a number of this is the first math that develop and you say why did he use and so there are some limitations to. This method so for example when when the binding becomes more and more stero specific then this capture program it becomes the last and the last. And so that you. You get to a situation where you get really really poor statistics so if you kept it pretty is it's a one party and one unit that means you need to you need to sample many many millions of trajectories to get good statistics. So we develop a target of Edwards and the idea is to minute the detail is very different. So instead of starting from a not official as Franco service weapon start from the site and with final the the victory. As a function of time and so when when the protein is is is is absorbed at the binding site and then with the trajectory. But we don't have a alter serve to capture this this trajectory. Instead we have a time caught off we simply cemented OP to a seven second time and then we record when. The top of that time whether or not the victory has terminated if you did it and we record the lifetime. So for you to tell you we have a life time either at which the trickery is terminated at what the cost of the time. And from that we calculate the fraction of trajectories that have been terminated at gave a unit of. And this is a was referred to as they survive a probe in the way of the sub I will probably need to as a function of time. And from that we can find the rate constant. So this it wasn't that they had a way to use but still we need to solve the problem. When you find it and this is basically the direction. Due to charges on the proteins you know steady interaction potential and to do that we use a static motto. So that's where you what you learn from Jackson. So so we have far protein monic you. So and I will modify that as diametric And if you can medium. Which is a diet for constant as appropriate for protein molecules this value is the ocean. About four and then we have the charge of the protein Chargers. That are humanity in this medium and then on the outside. It's a protein protein is a live environment then we have. On the other side we have a say going to die of a medium with a different doctor constant This is now about eighty four four for water so we have this space me problem with two different types of media. Four for the protein Monica an eighty for the solvent and the symphony we solve the problem equation two. Where pain the. The static energy for protein molecule and then we solve this for one protein molecule for the for protein A and it would do it for protein B. and then will for solving for the protein complex and then it would take the difference to get the energy of the interaction as a function of the separation of the two mana cues. Now this problem again to convert for that detail to shave the protein monikers away have to solve numeric only and it typically we we use. A finite a difference. Edwards and C. and said. This is a derivative So we represent the second two or three days as if I find a difference and then we solve the made. They result in measures matrix problem. Suffice to say this is a very time consuming problem and then you want to. Solve the problem. A few times as possible but if you want to actually do the broader than examinations then in principle have to solve this problem. Every step of your your your simulation and that's actually not. The time you just so you hate of along that this actually happened as has not been done and as a result when you actually do the brunt and I'm this nation you have to make drastic simplifications and that this indications you are poor when the proteins are R R R R. And that's when you actually need it to be the highest So you have this problem with dealing with. The you know just added part. Accurate and so we try to. Overcome this problem from a different perspective. And what we're trying to do was to find a way to capture the fact of the potential in A and equal way rather than through some innovations. So we came up with this. And it is good for me and her that data captures the fact of the internet campaign. With a common for you to do in the nation processors. So this is in the form of approximate a form in our for the rate constant So this has a form of what we refer to as a beta rate constant So this is a rate constant when you turn off. The next steady interaction. And so that you basically in your simulation will be full screen and those from the nations can be very efficient and instead they forced the putting is a captured a by a and for. Both of my factor you and over just the record region. So now what you have to do is basically the problem is and I'm very confined to this precise binding site. So you can sample and emit a number of conflagrations and if you calculate. The range you. And then you do a boy's mine for you to get the fact of the interaction potential. Now this is not something that we just throw down there and in fact this is true detailed analysis of the diffusion equation I want to get into the details but but suffice it to say it's now an again I want time as an approximation and the accuracy of this this approximate a foreman or depends on two things first. Depends on the the stairway Space Face city of the protein complex. So for example in our work for the by a motto. Were you have the case where the protein molecules are uniformly reactive. So this has to be have very specific. Binding complex and a segregated the interaction potential has to be in the range and that's exactly what we have when you have a natural state interactions. So the two requirements are then just by chance happened to be exact and what do we have and so. So that we can use this. Approximate a formula and this is the basis of basing our approach which were furred to as they transcend complex theory and yes there is a surety about it soon all arranged right. So all we explain the trends and converts part in a moment. But the. Clearly theories basis for me. Enter this approximate it before me enter and of course we want to. Since it is just an important such important part of our approach you will want to test its validity of any and. And we've done. Compared this form in a way that with a broader that makes a nation results for some four simplify tomatoes and the in addition will also tested against the results since I said I have this. And it is before me and so I can I can test. The approximation against this result. Now. This depends on the shape of the entire campaign show and not the problem actually even though Flamini can be solved in this way but the problem can be solved only for a limited number of potentials and so I was able to solve for two so one has a lot of respect dependence on the distance the other is a step function not that this. Has any physical meaning just a mathematical need to solve the problem. And so. The approximate for me when I when I scale things I get this about one point seven times from the four and then the I need a results at the exact results then. Listed here and so you see that the four different magnitudes of the interaction pertains to. The units of K. T. one K. T. up to nine K. T. they all have close agreement with the. Approximated from the inner so. So again this is just an aspiration of the test. Donna no one and no one said but it was the accuracy of the medical form in are now to give you a flavor of this trends in a complex theory. We can we can. Cultured in the form of a kinetic scheme as information that the association processors can be composed and use them to two steps the first step is the diffusion approach of the Toumani cues and then the Sigma step is the rearrangement of form the final complex. So we can capture that two step process by a kinetic scheme so we say to protein monikers and be they form this. Transit in complex with great constants of K. or D. and it is trying to convert can disassociate was written a K. of mind and body this trying to complex and also rearrange to form the final complex C. So the transit complex is basically the result of this is diffusion approach. It has. Said preachin in a war in Taishan close to the final complex but it has yet to form the specific short range directions of the final complex. And and. So you few treat. This trend the complex as a. Comedian that does not. Kim in eight and then you can you can find the overall rate constant in terms of the rate constant of the unit the individual stamps and so this has a property that that when the same going to stampede to fast. Then the first step becomes a rate determined so the overall rate constant becomes very close to the first step and this is a diffusion of step and. So that's what happens on the right half of the rate spectrum. So in this. It's spectrum. Ray said are higher than about a tenth of the homeowner percentage and isn't limited by diffusion whereas it's rate constant that are smaller than the four point two percent and it will be limited by the second step the the rearrangement will commission a change of stamp and. Within the diffusion limited regime there is also a range and that ranges than rate comes in the from ten to four to ten to six point one per second and the use of the rate constant that you would have when the diffusion is on by is to simply run that would be fusion whereas a higher rate of constants in the ten percent will be the case there were the diffusion is biased by static attraction. So in fact if you look at the proteins that are associated with rates beyond the six promoted percent and invariably you will see that they feature high any company charge surfaces. So you improve statics blue represents positive and red representing negative so usually they will have one protein that's Heinie positive charge one protein there will be negative charge and here I'm going for examples of all of those cases. So I just said being able to solve the right half of this problem and if you some more details about approach in particular how would you find the trends and complex. So the trends in complex. Is based on are you since you're describing the process of the distribution approach. So we can model the protein monitors as basically as a true rigid bodies and so the reality of. The relative rotation are already one Tasia and we actually use a way in on goes to represent the same. Degrees of freedom. So basically this is this what you can conquer when you solve rigid body problems in theoretical dynamics and so the the energy in the trans nation the rotation of space will feature a deep well and that calms about due to disobey civic interactions between the two protein Monny cues and that represents the the the the final the bomb state. And then when you're far away then you're going to have. Waken direction so that the and its surface is relatively flat. So the the transit complex is basically the dividing line between the divide is there between the two regimes. That is noted on the outer boundary of the over the state of well so that is a close to the banks that well your terms overturns a nation no rotation no degree but it does not have the stability in directions that gave rise to the deep well and. Most of the city. When you are within this deep well within your rotation is a significant restricted so that there were patient angle that in the sample has a very limited range. Whereas once you are out of there. Well then you can sample Wallace three hundred sixty degrees in rotation so the transit complex is basically the transition region been between those two regimes. So just to recap shown at our approach. So we decided we when we predicted the rate constant based on this approximate four manner. And this depends on the specification of the transit complex as I have just explained and then the beta rate constant we will detain by force three Bryan Danielson Asians and then the next step. He directed energy we will paint by solving the person equation. So we've now. There's a board room so we because when you only need to solve within the trans and complex and it is trying to convert typically you have separation between the morning. Five on trumps right. There's nothing that isn't a problem you want to say ten you need to ten twenty on some That's a long range. So we have a number of them. We all approach has a number of advantages but I don't I'm not into this. So highly technical I'm not going to get into this but just to show you one application of our approach and this. Is the prominence of a protein binding to you and this is. As you can imagine a larger system and weighs more than fifty thousand atoms involved and we can handle this because just because the the the the power of our approach. So this is a picture of the right goes on and this is the. The protein that's bond to a particular region of the right was and this is a piece of the rebels Omar R.N.A. and this is a toxic enzyme that actually binds to the to the our in a loop in action to create seed so that that serves to inactivate its rivals on a stops protein synthesis So this is a poxy. And this is so he is referred to as a rival toxin. And this is a you know large To view of. The complex of the rabbit hogs and with the particular robot. In a piece. And the. Structure of the rubble talks in ways just in the loop by itself and has been determined by X. or crystallography and then we actually modeled it this structure based on this and we simply superimposed the darn loop to the to what's on there our name to the ribozyme and then this model for the complex and. So the there is another interest in this in this system and as that is that demand the observed a rate Constantine this case is actually set a record. So the next week sees ten depends upon approaches eleven Pomona per second. So while quite interesting. You know how such a high rate constant was achieved. So you can also study the. To the association of the protein with just of the piece over the rebels Omar and they and that's sort of in the normal range of the sevens Pomona percent and so there is an additional for what is the magnitude meant when the red was almost loop present on the surface of the of the ribosome So we were interested in our region of the of this additional ten ten ten thousand rate handsome and there is no that's was a nice approach there is no free parameters. There are primitives about this. Tape. You know uniform way would only add it just any parameters in doing this sort of calculations are simply the by itself. Yeah yeah that's unaided are in the loop. And so there are two and one of the advantages that. That I skipped over was. We can tease out the different contributions to rather than just calculating a single red cons and we actually it contains are the contributions to the rate constant and we found that. So part of the contribution to the ten thousand and four. Additionally has in the cons and from the additional charges on the rebels and so the right was on these a large component is the rebels in our name which is a highly negative charge or the rebel toxin is a positive charge. So there is a narrow range nor range attraction so that contributes to about half of of the additional you handsome in about one hundred fold and then there is additional hundred for you. Handsome and that comes from short range fact. And this comes. By by reshaping the trends and complexes this is a trend a complex of the eye of the isolated right was Omar in A and then in the context of the intact arrival zone. What you see is that this complex cannot is not compatible with them for example you run for caches you don't utilize this. Class to well so. So this in the neighboring rebels own protein then modify the transit complex. So as a result now the transit company is a race shaped and this ratio of the rivals in the transit complex and allows the interactions between. The protein and the end of Darnay loop to be particularly strong so that So this is through ratio in the transit complex and that contributes the additional one hundred fold over all it's a rigid are treated as rigid this isn't it correct in the in the as long as the flexibility does not become limited and. So that's why we stick to the higher half of the rate spectrum and this is the case the Reagan word this sort of flexibility fast so that they don't become written in one thousand. And so with now a made this already made a prediction matter select it may appear at a web server that you can actually submit your protein complex and make predictions. So so so this is you asked about whether we're term promenaders so we predict this automatic and then them in the we're not in our prime interest and just to give you an idea of the of the performance so with such an interest here and we're following the forty nine. Protein complex's word rate constant have been measured and will fit in those complex in outcomes. To print the value is predicted by the web server and then this is sort of the comparison so we get this sort of. Agreement between this autumn prediction matter and observed rate Constance. You go. But what was wrong or if you are right. For those you're right. So what is making the change is the attraction. So that can vary the rate comes in by several orders of magnitude and it's diffusion emitted it's diffusion except the diffusion is buyers' despise the diffusion as opposed to unbiased diffusion so. Speeding up the diffusion through the traction. All right so and it is proving complex economy and different shapes in the forms and so there is so is high need diversified so. So our methods don't really care about what what what is this protein what that protein so so so so. So we now we claim that we've now solved the half of the social problem that's the half that is limited by diffusion. All right so that. OK That's OK go to is fine. A good so now the problem is out of work done. It's is by little solutions body in the in the cell. It's really far from being diluted and so this. The inside of a cell is is a crowded always all sorts of macromolecules and in the aggregate a concentration is extremely high. So this is a straight shot of the of the crowd and is so full of the of the of the of the sale is so you get a large and small when the protein spill is already did it is in the binds and sometimes they aggregate into five groups. So all of these happen you know how many of crowded conditions and the question is whether or not the crowded conditions when you fact the physical properties such as the by and the by new rate constants and. So we've done. Studies see a model citizen and then they show that indeed the crowded conditions the cancer giving you fact the different. Physical properties. And so so so and so we are studying the. The fact of sand in a crowded conditions. So the first question that we ask is when we would have conditioned then when they approached it based on a pair. The. Here's a question of cost is that still valid. And so to so interest this question. Some time ago. Ron and I'm exterminations So here we have a box of hot fears and then because fears it was something label one of them as a and others several others said to be and then the rest as Crowder's and then. So the bottom mockery of this is to me is quite high. About forty percent. And so. So we we as soon as the two particles approach away assume that of the they reacted so we calculated the survival. Pretty as a function of time and they will use that human out how skip roach to predict and that's given by the sign of the curve and we actually get pretty good agreement between the summation and the theory. Now the theory is done by. A commune for the fact of the Crowder's and it is coming two ways. And one is the there is a huge fact if I traction. Do the Crowder's between the the attraction between the protein monitors by the Crowder's and that has to do with the fact that when two protein Monny cues are close to each other the volume exclusion. OVER THE OVER THE LAST thing you if you would have to to Monica to separate so there is so crowded then your so then space is at a premium so you want to minimize the use of space and that's when when the proteins are associated So there is a huge factor of the driving force or attraction due to the Crowder's and say going to the Crowder's serve to reduce the diffusion constant. Because these are becoming obstacles to swinging from one place and another position you have to avoid those Crowder's so that fission constant is reduced and turns out that those to you. Facts act. We oppose each other so. So the net effect is actually quite modest and. Worse yet. This is not a you know this is excellent. Vonnie type of track and this somebody called me from expletive on me. In fact it's not good for words from you know static effects. Depending on what kind of progress you have so your progress on charge of it and then so you're not going to have any you know static effects. Now you're you've got a charge and then you walk you are going to yes I mean we're art yourself. Electricity is a dollar which is where you work right. Regardless. Yeah. So they know they were what effect on the day I went back and looked at in the so the fact of a battery constant now becomes not true not eighty but somewhere between about fifty and so the. So the steady interaction is strange because of the reduced the screen in in that regard. So so anyway so we can convert those it to you. Facts. By by modifying our proximate a form in or so now the base rate companies and the modified because now the diffusion content is reduced. Now we have this. Fact interaction due to crowding. So this could be could involve and could also be a modification of the United standing interaction. So by. Accommodating for those the facts then we can gain us our native formular and. So we have ways of calculating those you facts and it just to skip over this and and get to. One set of. OK So this is we're collaborating with Gideon Schreiber where the wise men used to to do so they've measured the rate constant of two protein Pam and and various. Crowding conditions and they found that it basically the Crowder's don't do much in and that's. Somewhat surprising in the sense that if you look at the diffusion constand of proteins under those conditions the action of the division on the slowed down by about five full days it would expect the rate constant to also be slow dong. But then if you convert for the effect of extraction to the Crowder's this to you. Facts almost so that you get. Essentially and now. Net You fact so. So this is for or calculations. So to summarize. Showing you of that here we have the advantage and approach the trends in conflict theory then there were implemented through static calculations and brought in dynamics and Asians and this methodology for automated would claim accurate predictions of rate constants and diffusion sets a limit on association rate constants and this in the range of ten to force to twenty six point one percent again for I'm biased diffusion But you know static tracking combine POV this. Limited by more than three What is the magnitude and their wide range of social rate comes and allows proteins to perform different functions used in different kinds to suit their particular functional requirements and find any. Association on the crowded condition can also be modeled and when the facts of interaction and diffusion are good for and just funny. People in the group that contributed to this work and for fun. Thank you for intention. Thank you very much for that very we have any more questions about this so that decision is far more complicated. And the raising is that to disassociate you have to worry about the short range interactions and those are harder to model and so we're just beginning to note at this short range of facts that we were right. Some Monica dynamics and that different representation can be at a mistaken walking most of the Course screen. Yeah so. So that's the kind of things that we have to account for the way to reduce right road were to well it was very close to live very good. There's you are the world we remember we were the workers are we. Your yes we were. So you are right the larger the whole of the world right. This deep well yes computer. You are right. The second question was this road is the wrong approach World War for the right. So right I mean it's a deficiency it's all random and you can you can actually have a complex a word the ramparts of proteins are in contact. So that's can happen. Yes but I want different kind of hold your target. You can translate a complex between protein a crowd or so that can happen and if this happens a lot of then our approach will not work so so the car will the factory become traps and the question for some perspective. I don't think you comment on this you have this spectrum of really huge predictions. If you had to sort of classify the percentage of proteins that would fall in one person and I think I think you asked this question. So I can. Yeah so. So we have not really done by the way did do I limited a set of proteins a set of I'm A name it is all relative. I think it is one hundred eighty proteins. So it's not so limited so fought and fought. A particular set. About eighty percent of the proteins fall on the high end of the range that we can model about twenty percent of falls on the ring in the range that we can't it's there a way to glance at a protein structure and it's going to go and one side or the other because yeah yeah so provided you have to know know provide you have the structure of both before and after having if you have a structure of both the structures of both the complex as well as state. Because then you know if you come from here and there was a math that actually tells us whether or not if you saw automated method I can actually tell when you to fail. OK All right well thank you very much.