GBU Lunch lecture. My name is Michael Best. I'm Executive Director of the Institute for Group on Technology, and I'm really glad to see you all here for this inaugural lunch of the semester. And for who is this their first time being at an iPad GBU lunch lecture? It's a bunch of architecture students. Who are students registered for the class? Yeah, we have a very small number this semester, which is super weird. And so, encourage folks to register. They have till tomorrow. It's a one unit class, and you get free lunch, and you come and hear a bunch of amazing speakers on Thursdays 1230-130, basically. So how could that be wrong? And I think the grading is, did you attend? So, like, how is that not a really good deal? So, we would happily have more students because the CAP, I think, is another 30 or so students. So spread the word, really. I think it's really a great opportunity. For those who are new to IPAT, the Institute for People and Technology, it's one of the ten inter disciplinary research institutes on campus. I like to say we're the heart and soul of the Georgia Tech Research Enterprise. And one of the things we do, looking at College of Design students is really work hard to try to bring um, folks from Ivan Allen and the College of Design, increasingly Scheller in conversation with folks in computing and engineering. So if you're interested at all in that enormous intersection, we're your IRI. You want to be your favorite IRI. And you're welcome to join us. If you are new to IPAT, or even if you aren't new to IPAT, but if not done this yet, please go to iPad dot gotech dot EDU and sign up in the Contact us area. You can sign up for our newsletter. That newsletter will include weekly announcements for the IPAT GVU Lunch lecture series. It'll also include other activities we're doing. For instance, this semester we will have our interactivity program in conjunction with the MSHCIPgram which includes opportunities for student poster sessions. And a variety of other events, including next month, we will have a town hall. The IPAT Town Hall is a chance to just come and familiarize yourself with other programs we have within the institute, including research infrastructure we have, like maker spaces and craft labs, as well as funding opportunities, a award program and other things that would be interesting, hopefully to you, whether you're a student or faculty. Before I introduce Alan, let me just tease the lecture series a little bit more by giving you a small foreshadowing of some of the speakers we have lined up for the program this semester. So a week from today, we're going to have Professor Rich De M of the School of Cybersecurity and Privacy. And the title of his talk is Roots of distrust, modern technology and the impact of a 19th century voter suppression plan. Now, if you know rich, or even if you kind of can read between the lines of that title, it will be scandalous and drama. And it will be really exciting. He's one of the nation's, I think, most poignant scholars in the area of voter security. Focuses a lot on Georgia and Fulton County. You know, gets into a lot of good trouble. So come hear Rich talk about the state of democracy as he sees it, especially from a perspective of technology security. That's in one week. And then the next Thursday will be assistant prop named Abiba Behane from Trinity. The following one is the Chair of Art and Design from North Eastern. And then the next one is somebody from GTRI. So hopefully, what you can see is it's a mix of folks from on campus, eminent faculty from other universities, both domestic and foreign and even some folks from GTI. And that is just the beginning. The final three lunch lectures are one will be composed of our C grant winners. So those are faculty who've received IPAT C grants, another will be dissertation lightning talks being arranged, I think, by digital media. Am I right about that? So folks who are in the final stages of their PhD, and then the final one is our FLY scholars. So that's student awardees from the MSN PhD programs across campus, who are doing work that's at the intersections of people and technology. So is there any questions or issues about the program just before I introduce Alan? Okay, so it's really my distinct pleasure to introduce our speaker today. Alan Hyde is an associate professor of sociology in the School of history history and sociology, HSOC. Okay. It changed its name like a decade ago, but I'm still stumbling on that. And he's also, I'm very pleased to say, the initiative lead within IPAT for responsible and ethical technologies. He's a quantitative scholar whose main research areas are stratification and inequality, urban sociology, work and occupations, climate and disaster resilience, and immigration. And he's currently researching the effects of race, ethnicity, and immigration status on home ownership, social and demographic change in Clarkston, Georgia. And a PI for the Youth Advocacy for Resilience to Disasters program funded by the NSF. And I think we're going to hear quite a bit in particular about that program. It's particularly, I think, germane to us today that we're going to hear about climate resiliency because it feels like a spring day out there right now, and yet, I think we're all getting ready for a crazy day of weather tomorrow. So without further ado, it's my pleasure to introduce Thank you, everybody. How is the mic doing? Can you y'all hear me okay? Cool. So thank you for the introduction, and I appreciate everybody being here. So I'm going to talk about some of our work on NSF grant called Youth Advocacy for Resistance to Disasters, Empowering youth to be advocates for change. I also want to acknowledge that this is a team. So we have our COPI, any Lukess, Nisha Bushwe, doctor Philip Amonga and doctor McLain at the Harambe House, which is an environmental justice organization in Savannah. Um, we also have our project manager, Mustafa Shabaz, Daoud Shibaka, who is at the Harambe House, as well. Iris T N here at Georgia Tech, Tim Cone, Melton Memdar, Storm Robinson, Russ Clark, who is also here in the crowd today, Kim Cobb, Katie O'Connell, Olivia Chapman. But importantly, I also want to acknowledge some of our graduate students, Milton Yusufi and Michelle Rechner, and Michelle is here. I may call on Michelle a little bit later to see if she wants to just answer some questions that you may have, as well, as well as Sarita Smith and Reggie Slater and Maria Susa. So just a little bit about me, I think, actually sometimes because a lot of students are here, sometimes it's good to like, we see you see professors and you think, like, Oh, they had this plan, and they knew exactly how they were going to get there, and, like, you don't really understand the context and complex journey. So just a little bit about me. I'm originally from North Alabama, grew up in a town called Albertville or Boaz. And I got into sociology, I think. Originally, I thought I was going to be bio premed. I went to the University of Alabama Birmingham, planning that. But we growing up, I did a lot of youth mission trips with my church. And we took several trips to New Orleans often because, well, a lot of mission trips go there. New Orleans is also a really important cultural capital for the South. I think the culture there is, like, quite unique. And part of that began to a lot of churches. Many of y'all, if you went to different kind of churches, you often go to homeless shelters or you do like soup kitchens and things like that. And I was really interested in this issue of poverty and homelessness, which is this recurring thing. And really wondering, are things like soup kitchens or some of even these shelters that provide very temporary relief? Are they really addressing this larger issue of homelessness, poverty and inequality? Um, I then went to the University of Alabama Birmingham, which is a big university in Alabama, thinking I was going to be pre med, but I then switched my major three times and added a double major in history and sociology. I still graduated on time, you know, so if there are any undergrads here and you're still trying to figure things out, like, just it's okay. We all kind of figure out our journey as we go. Um, I then moved up to Connecticut and got a PhD in sociology from the University of Connecticut. Connecticut was very different, very big culture shock. I got in trouble for saying, Mam. On the first day I was in Connecticut to a woman that was from, I believe, the Bronx or maybe Brooklyn. She was very offended that I said Mam to her. So there is some culture shock and learning there. But while I was there, there was a massive tornado outbreak in Alabama in the Southeast. Does anybody remember this in 2011? There were over, I believe, 324 tornado related deaths across six states and 24 fatalities caused by thunderstorms. I think Alabama, there was over 50 tornadoes that broke out in one day. This ultimately affected my hometown. So when I went back home after that, it looked completely different. All the trees in downtown Albertville had changed, right? So I wasn't studying disasters in grad school or even undergrad, but it connects to some of the things that we've experienced. And then, while I was at, I was at the University of Alabama Birmingham 2005-2009. So does anybody want to take a guess what this is? Hurricane Katrina. So Hurricane Katrina hit New Orleans in August right around the time that I started at UAB. As a freshman in a dorm, we had to then in the middle of the night, we had to go into the hallways and put books over our head, like we were in middle school. If you're from the south, you often learn to do this for tornadoes. But we had to Katrina was still a tropical storm as it came up through Birmingham. And so, I love New Orleans. I went back a couple of years later, but this issue of Katrina and disasters and how does it relate to poverty and inequality is something that I'm really interested in. And so when we think of disasters in the Southeast, Hurricane Katrina often comes to mind. In 2005, Katrina struck the Gulf Coast, killing almost 2000 people and left millions displaced in a path of destruction. You all know that story. The world knows that story. What's often overlooked is that the systems designed to prevent damage often fail in disasters, and the most vulnerable people are often left worse off than they were before the disaster occurred. Hurricane Katrina left images that will forever be etched in our minds. Regardless of where disasters occur, they disproportionately affect black and brown communities. Black people in the United States have the highest risk for the negative effects from hurricanes, tornadoes, heat waves, and flooding, especially in coastal areas. Further, the most vulnerable are often children and the elderly, and they often have difficult recoveries afterwards. The aftereffects of disasters like Katrina can be especially devastating for youth. In a study in New Orleans Post Katrina, they found that a large proportion of youth had experienced trauma or PTSD as a result of the destruction, uneven recovery, and displacement of families. And if we think of Georgia, we see a very similar pattern where black communities are often most vulnerable to disasters related to climate change like flooding and hurricanes. This is especially the case, though. So this is some data from some work that Marshall Shepard, as well as some other colleagues did on climate vulnerability in Georgia. If you look at the bottom right, this is kind of the most up to date kind of assessment of climate vulnerability, but you can see that Metro Atlanta and Savannah, which have pretty significant black populations have some of the highest risk for climate change. Now, flash back to Savannah, Georgia in 2016. Imagine this is a hypothetical story, but just play along with me. Two kids, Ben and Malika are outside playing in the yard, dark clouds appear over their heads. Their mom yells for them to come inside as they see this warning on the TV and hear calls for everyone to evacuate the city. Their car was in the shop so they couldn't drive away. They didn't want to leave their 67-year-old neighbor, Miss Rose, that was wheelchair bound. They knew the power would probably go out for days if not weeks, like it always does. And with what generator, what could they do? They went inside of their house, like they always did, covered the windows with wood and hunkered down for days. And when they came outside, this is what they saw. So this is actually a picture from it's actually a picture from one of the suburbs of Savannah during Hurricane Matthew, and it actually ended up being one of the neighborhoods where Miss Williams, one of the teachers that worked with our project, she lives in this neighborhood. And so they saw their neighborhood and homes flooded and people were being rescued and bost. Recovery was at a snail's pace. After the cleanup efforts finally reached them, things go back to Business uneral, meaning infrastructure systems aren't really changed. This is where our fits come in. We're not really trying to build another disaster preparedness system. We're focusing on the Bens and Malkas and Savannah and all across the country. We developed a middle school curriculum that focuses on building children, empowering them in their communities to be resilient to disasters. Building upon years of research and community engagement with the Smart Sea level sensor project, we developed a diverse and exciting team with partners from Georgia Tech, Savannah State, the University of Minnesota, the City of Savannah, the Harambe House, and the Savannah and Chatham County Public School System. So why do we focus on youth? Well, a couple of different reasons. So first, we identified youth as a large yet vulnerable population on Savannah's West Side communities and developed a youth advocacy program to address their needs. Parents and families are often busy and can engage in many activities, and youth are an important link to parents and their family networks, and their voices can often inspire change. Further, this program provides important educational opportunities that can act as a kind of pre workforce development in relation to disaster and emergency preparedness. And so one of the things is when we originally started this grant back in 2020, when we started our original plan, we thought we were going to focus on adults, but we really hear that there's so many community engaged efforts these days, especially targeting adults that there's a lot of burnout. There also is mistrust of universities. Georgia Tech may not have the best reputation in all communities. And so we decided that youth would be a different way to engage, but also then reach their families. But they're also really an important kind of they're our future, so we really need to invest in youth. So what did we do? We developed yards or youth advocacy for resistance to disasters. It's a 14 session curriculum, pre piloted it as a summer camp at Georgia Tech, Savannah campus, and we did another pilot at Mercer Middle School, Title one school in October and November of 2022. I'm going to put that in the background. Essentially, students learn about disaster resilience from the perspective of environmental justice. They then develop virtual mapmaking skills through Map Spot, a custom mapmaking and engagement tool shown in the video in the bottom right. This was developed by Yani Lukess, who is in LMC here at Georgia Tech to design green infrastructure solutions to disaster resilience in their communities. They then learn about civic engagement and youth advocacy and present their plans and maps to local leaders to advocate for change in their community. And so these are some pictures from our efforts in Savannah. Our curriculum teaches students about disasters and about the ways to design and improve their neighborhoods and communities to be more resilient with hands on activities like our mobile floodplain simulator, which illustrates the differences between gray, traditional infrastructure, like levees and also green infrastructure like retention ponds and parks and their ability to reduce flooding. And you can kind of see the kids light up as they engage with the flood simulator. Michelle is one of the leaders of, like, how we did this. And essentially the kids develop action plans based on infrastructure solutions to disasters. So they could think about green and gray infrastructure solutions as they're kind of re imagining their communities. Um, students use Map Spot, a collaborative mapmaking tool to help young people examine challenge and redefine the stories that data tell about natural disasters in their communities. And you can see in the video on the top right, which I'll start now, they examine inundation estimates for flooding and overlay that on their maps of their communities that they have drawn earlier in the session. They can also look at other data showing social and infrastructure vulnerabilities to complement what they are learning in the classroom through a drop down menu. So essentially, students are this is a multi kind of disciplinary curriculum where it kind of makes teachers a little anxious if they think about wanting to do it because it's so multi disciplinary. But we have students look at different data layers about their community, thinking about assets and vulnerabilities. We try to emphasize assets, but often kids focus on the problems. So it's really a challenge, I think, going forward, is, how can we make it more asset focused and really get the kids to focus on assets? So the goal is then to use that data collected and analyzed through Map Spot to identify challenges in their community and to design green infrastructure solutions to disaster vulnerability. They identify the benefits of their solutions and practice presenting their action plan before doing a formal presentation to leaders to advocate for change and improve disaster resilience in their own backyards. And so you can see here some of the kids preparing, especially in the first summer camp that we did, the first summer camp was just the first time we did it, so they were doing kind of basic tri folds where they drew a lot. So also kids that liked art also like our program as well. We didn't do an assessment and evaluation to validate the program and the effectiveness of the curriculum using quantitative survey data from the students, as well as qualitative feedback from the students and teachers. And we also did an interview of decision makers who attended those sessions to get better understanding of, like, what did they think was successful about the program and not. So what have we found so far? Overall, we found, I mean, I guess everybody wants to say that it's somewhat of a success. I mean, but I probably am biased. But essentially, this is what we found. We found that students increase their self efficacy for advocacy behaviors. So by self efficacy, it means that students think that if they want to be an advocate for change, then it's going to have some kind of actual effect, that they basically have some kind of power, specifically related to understanding, preparing for and responding to natural disasters. And they also increase their understanding of the importance of course topics like infrastructure and data use. Resilience is still a fancy word for middle school students. We find that that's one of the words that they struggle with the most. Environmental justice, when you try and teach middle schoolers environmental justice, at the end, they typically think it's protecting the environment. So environmentalism, environmental justice is something that they kind of struggle with. So that's something we're going to keep working on. Parents noted that their children really enjoyed the program and liked that they were learning things that are not being taught in the classroom. So, honestly, a lot of the kids don't know their parents' cell numbers. They also don't have any kind of emergency plan, even in Savannah. So we had kids actually develop like a home emergency plan and just kind of making aware that they probably should memorize their parents' cell in case their own cell phone goes out, that they have a way to contact their families. And we did this twice as a summer camp and once as an after school program. So what are we going to be doing in the future? So we have several next steps. First, we're going to continue to analyze the reports and the data. We've already published one article 1 is forthcoming on some of our research, and we have a lot of other papers in progress. We're thinking about expanding this within Chatham County. So Chatham County is the county that Savannah is a coastal county where Savannah is located. As well as throughout coastal Georgia, but also potentially thinking about rural areas, like we saw the devastation that Helene had throughout rural Georgia, like Valdosta, all the way up to Western North Carolina. So I don't think that this should just be a coastal program. There will be some adjustments that we'll have to make if we move inland, like places even like Atlanta. But that is our goal. Our innovative curriculum design will be made available through an open source learning environment that can be transferred to communities across the country, helping to develop a new generation of leaders, advocates, and promoters of disaster resilience. Um so we also with funding from BBIS were able to do this in South Africa. So we did a similar program this fall in Cape Flats of South Africa. So Cape Town is one of the major cities in South Africa. I don't know. I probably should have included a map, but so the Central Business District of Cape Town is here. There's a big mountain called Table Mountain that kind of divides the city from what's called the Flats. This is a highly segregated high poverty area on the other side of the mountain, the Cape Flats. And so we did this program there as you can see, there is different kind of infrastructure that is available there. We were still able to do Map Spot, but we weren't able. There was one electrical outlet for the entire room. And so we had to then split that outlet to do some of the technology that we did here in the United States. And so we were able to still do MPSpot. The kids were super interested in not only what the situation is in um, Cape Town. But also, they were curious about the United States. They looked at some of the data. They were really interested in differences by poverty and race, and they were not surprised to find that Black and brown communities in the United States have similar challenges that they do in South Africa. As you all know, Apartheid ended, 1994, still significant inequalities in South Africa. They were much more attuned to issues of racism, I think, than you would see here with students in the United States. Um but it was still a success. It was cold. So it was in August, late August of 2024. Do y'all know what season late August is in Cape Town? It's winter. So that's why the kids even though it was August, it was 95 degrees here. It was like 40 degrees there. So you can see some of the kids are in, like, hoodies and things like that. I think it's really important to empower youth to tell their stories. We found that we did the curriculum there. It was a two day version of the curriculum. For these youth, they were we taught them about climate resilience and disasters. That was not what they were as much concerned about. So in their community, they said that when they go outside, they see issues of violence, drugs, unemployment. So they wanted to address issues of gangsterism. And so when they developed their action plans, we had to pivot, they really weren't seeing why climate resilience was super relevant to them. We wanted to make whatever action plan they develop to be relevant to whatever their most immediate needs were. And so they developed action plans to address gangsterism and kind of youth empowerment in their community. And so, ultimately, you can see them kind of start to design those plans and address them here. And Mustafa Shabaz was one of the guys, our project manager, but he was one of the important folks kind of leading these conversations. And, I mean, he really said that it's really important to not hold kids back, like, kind of think about what is most important to them. Like, obviously, you want to teach them about maybe climate sustainability related issues. That might not be their most important need. So sometimes you have to pivot. And I think that's something that Sear Hub has experienced with a Smart sea level sensor project. They found we came in to Savannah really wanting to address flooding. But then when you talk to community members, they're like, we are not as concerned about flooding as we are air quality. Things like this when you do community engaged research, sometimes you have to pivot. You can still address those issues that you think are important, but you have to prioritize what the community feels is important first. And so this is our full group in winter out there, they were freezing, not really happy, and the sun was in their eyes as they were trying to take this picture in our yard T shirts at the end of the program. And so we do hope to continue to do work in South Africa. I think that's a priority that I have. We'll just have to seek additional funding for that. But overall, that is a brief kind of overview of our program and research. This is a list of all the folks here. It was funded by the National Science Foundation, but also BBIS as well as to some extent, IPAT here at Georgia Tech. And I think that is it. Any questions, comments? Thank you. And then also, Michelle is here. If y'all have any questions for Michelle, sorry to put you on the spot, but you can also ask questions. Yep. Youth advocacy for resilience to disasters. Let me put it on the first slide. Yeah. Sure. So are there existing instruments that measure resilience? So it kind of depends on so this is something that we actually talked about in a workshop in South Carolina recently, you got to define, okay, what are we who are we wanting to be resilient? And then what are we being resilient against, and what is the goal of that? I think right now, we don't have measures of resilience. The way we are trying to assess this is that there has been research that shows that self efficacy and advocacy behaviors can help improve resilience. So we're kind of measuring some of these things that other people have found to improve resilience, but we don't have a direct measure of, are these kids more resilient? Now, I can't I would be great to do a follow up if there was a hurricane to see. But then it's also kind of awkward to ask them. You just went through a disaster. Like, how did you and your family react? So it is hard to assess, like, how do they react when an actual disaster occurs. There are programs that people have done AR and VR kind of disaster simulations that can cause kids to cry. So we haven't really necessarily done that. But we did have one kid cry just even talking about disasters, so we also have to be sensitive to some of those things as well. I think there is a question over here? Yeah, I think from an infrastructure standpoint, we didn't see a whole lot of that. We did, as far as students thinking because these are middle school students. But what we did see more on the social side, right? So they began to notice, why are there no hospitals on one entire side of town? And so some of the action plans or why are there no doctors offices on this side of town. So one of the action plans that this group developed was to develop a resilience hub that then had some kind of medical facility, but we also tried to explain building a hospital is probably out of the scope of budget for something for the city to do, but could we do something to address that systemic issue. But when it came to infrastructure, I don't know, Michelle, do you feel like we would be able to address that? Yeah, I feel like part of it is, you know, making them aware of, like, they didn't even really understand MS to begin with, and I called these spatial disparities. So, it started out just kind of trying to introduce them to spatial data in general, like how I can inform decision making. But yeah, like, we tried to teach about green infrastructure while at the same time not doing, this is exactly what green infrastructure is, so they still had some flexibility and, like, creative processes. So we did show, like, canals. So Savannah has some canals, kind of like New Orleans, but they're much smaller than New Orleans canals. So we did show those and show, like, that flooding can occur around those, which is kind of what it's intended to do in some ways. But we also showed other types of I guess, features like the Savannah River and also the coast, but not as much on infrastructure, more about those, ecological systems. So the students began to notice that. Yeah. Other questions. Yep. So I'm from Savannah Oh, nice. Program. But I'm kind of curious about is, what is the follow up with students? Do they continue to be part of any kind of program afterwards? Just kind of like ints the idea to. Yeah, so Mercer Middle School is where we did the pilot. We're probably did worse at following up with youth in the summer camps because they're coming from sometimes all over the country. But at the Mercer Middle School. So they are developing a basically, they're doing steam certification at the school, so that then allows them to develop this cohort of students that are going to be, I think, called Planet tarians or something like that that are going to be kind of focusing on this and going through the school. So there's a school route. We also encourage them to look at other programs like the city of Savannah has a youth leadership program. We encourage them to go there. We also encourage them to think about the Black Youth Leadership Development Institute that the Harambe House does. So the teacher, it would be great. Since this was only a year ago, it would be great to then follow up and see if the teacher has found that these students are staying engaged on these topics or not. Um but I think since it was so recent, we still don't have, like, a solid assessment of, like, what are they doing now? Yeah. Yep. So that's one thing I thought that I had in there that I didn't really cover. So one of the challenges is well, maybe I'll step back and say some of the good things. I meant to include pictures, but apparently in this version, forgot to include them. But we did have senators or staffers from Senator Warnock and Asos office attend the Mercer Middle School presentations. They loved it. They gave us feedback. They actually gave me a bunch of federal grants, none of which were really relevant, but they gave me lots of things. They were really excited. But typically, what the challenge is, you see cities and, I guess, even state representatives kick stuff back to the youth and the group that's doing some of these ideas, and what you really need is a budget and that would be related to infrastructure that then could implement this. So I think in future versions, we need to budget for that. Otherwise, we also asked the kids, if your plans don't get implemented, do you think it's still important? And they said, Yes, because A, we think that people should listen and they should get. Implemented, but also be that it's just really important to kind of us to learn about this and also other people to learn about it and raise awareness of these issues even if our specific plans don't happen. So I think in future versions, we would like to include some kind of budget that allows some of the plans to go forward or agree to work with organizations that have that budget already, that could then do it. So, let's say it's a school, so the school would have a budget set aside that could then lead to some change around the school that helps it become more resilient. Yep. Yeah. Mm hm. Right. Yeah. Rebuild. Right. Right. Yeah. Right. Yeah, I mean, Yeah, I think we do see that demographically people are moving more to the coast, even though we're showing all these projections of sea level rise. I don't. There's a variety of reasons why this is occurring. Part of it is because People want to live near the coast and people can do more remote work. Now, I think we've seen kind of coastal cities in Georgia and South Carolina. More people are moving to those areas because they can work remotely. But the other issue is that federal disaster relief funds tend to go to homeowners. And so it not only is just encouraging homeowners to build there, but also renters don't get that aid. So only the property owners would get that aid. So we actually see that sometimes people will add renovations and build up their property value. So they take out loans, do renovations. Then the federal government provides loans based on their property value that then basically pays for their renovations. So there are some issues with federal aid. I'm not saying we shouldn't have federal aid. We're going to need federal aid, but I do think these are things that I mean, this research isn't exactly on that, but I do think it's something that we have to talk about, and it actually is probably driving more inequality because it tends to focus on homeowners and not renters. Now a lot of these areas. Uh huh. Yeah, yeah. Mm hm. It Right. One of the difficult things is in the middle school curriculum now, I think they talk about disasters and hazards, like, I guess, they kind of natural disasters and hazards. I mean, in our proposal, we explain that there's nothing completely there's not 100% natural disaster. These are often because of social issues related to the infrastructure, related to where people are moving, but it's hard to teach middle school students that complex of a thing at first. So we're trying to get at some of this kind of this topic, we try to teach some of the kids about it, but the issue is that the curriculum talks about natural disasters first. So we do kind of see that. I think the youth that we worked with, they see how these things are social and not just, like, an act of God. We really kind of tried to push against that. We in Georgia, I think we can't I'm not sure what the current state of how you can talk about climate change as the main cause. We do briefly talk about it, but we can't get into there's limits on what public school teachers can talk about. So Yeah. Right. Mm hmm. Yeah, yeah. Right. So sometimes unfortunately, some of the flooding areas are around or could be more expensive property, but sometimes flooding occurs, especially in flooding occurs around rivers which have low property value. So sometimes people don't have a choice. Now, if we make a choice if we have the ability to make a choice about where we live, it would be wise to maybe not live there. Sorry, next question. Yeah. Strategies that you guys to use Mm hmm. Silence. How did you guys talk Yeah, yeah. I mean, it was also a two day version of the camp, so we really didn't get to know the kids as much in. So usually they make their action plans like eight sessions, nine sessions in, but we were trying to do this on the first day or maybe the second day. So we had less time to really make that connection and trust with the youth. We did also have, though, their youth leaders as part of the activities. They probably should have had a little bit more training and engagement, so they weren't as engaged as we would have liked. So it was really, I guess, what we started the project starts about what is community. So we talk about community, have them draw pictures of their community, and immediately they start drawing pictures of guns and things in their pictures. So we didn't This started to raise some alarm bells. And then when we started to ask you ask the youth, what do they want to develop an action plan on. They all said, one question that I had is that because they're deciding this is the most important issue in their community or because that's what adults have told them is the most important issue in their community, it's unclear so we wanted to let the kids kind of guide where they went with their action plan. But it was I was just done. Because we did a two day version, it just kind of happened pretty quickly. But it is a sensitive topic, and that's one of the things is if you ask people to draw their community, especially kids, instead of asking them, you're getting a lot of information in a way that's not invasive. So when you ask kids to draw or maybe even say, like, tell me about home. Like, what do you see, smell, touch, here that will give you an idea without asking awkward questions that we didn't want to ask those questions, and I didn't even know until we got there how difficult the situation can be. So yeah. Stick with middle schoolers your future studies or moving on to upper grades, high schools get better under school situations. Yeah, so this is actually a topic we've debated quite a bit. We found that ninth graders, so we did sixth to eighth, but we found that students that just finished eighth grade, the rising ninth graders do the best. So we did a summer camp that was just targeting them, and they did amazing. That's because a lot of kids don't really think of their community in relation to other communities. They just kind of are I don't know, a lot of people talk about main character, main character syndrome, but, like, you're just kind of going through life and just thinking about you and, like, how do you interact in your community. As kids get older, they start to think relationally and like, Okay, here's how somebody else is experiencing something or here's how my community is different from somewhere else. So I think we do find that older kids are better. Now the teachers say, even if younger kids aren't good at this, it's good to expose them to it and start to get them to think that way. So we've had debates over whether this be high school, middle school because there's you can get better action plans with older kids, but you're getting people to think differently if you do younger kids, if that makes sense. You have Russ? I'm just going to add one of one of the reasons it comes down to why a lot of these programs we do with middle school. Oh, yes. It's just high school students are too distracted by all the other things they're doing. They have cars, they have jobs, they have organized sports. It's harder to get them to commit to coming to something like this and being involved in this after school program or a Saturday program. And that's just one of the realities of some of these youth programs that we've done, like be seismic and other engagement, it's just hard to get high school students to engage sometimes. So after school programs in particular are hard because you're competing with sports, jobs, especially for high school, but sports jobs, music, dance, all these things. So we actually are thinking about working with steam certifying schools on doing project based learning in the classroom. We thought that would be too much for teachers to, like, us to be like, Here's the curriculum, but actually teachers are looking for project based learning. So to get those athletes to get people that are maybe a bit more flaky, it would be better to do it in the classroom. And that steam certifying schools are probably the way that we could do that. Yeah. Question. Hi. Yeah, I was curious. Insofar a lot of this ispace by your community. Like, if you either have seen kids who have recently moved or thinking ahead to how often might involve, like, moving migration, like what that might look like for people who have recently moved s place or otherwise. Yeah, yeah, no, I think that's a good question. I mean, we had So when we do the summer camps, the kids are not just in one neighborhood. They're coming from different areas. And then they get to learn about different parts of the, like, let's say, the Savannah area. But then we also had a young woman, I think. Was she from Chicago or I can't remember. She was from somewhere else. So there is benefit to Evan doing this program in places that you're not as familiar with. But this issue of migration is something that we can consider, and I think that might be better for older students, but I think that's a great idea. Any other questions? I don't even know what time it is, so. What is the balance of teaching them about the bigger issue in communities and then things they can do themselves if there is a disaster like action the balance between those two? So the way the curriculum works is there's more focus on the action plan, but we really want it also. They have one particular activity where they have to they take home something that talks about the family action plan and focuses on what they can do. We had even within the action plan that's kind of the community oriented one, some of the kids took stuff on their own. So one youth, one young man in Mercer Middle School, he found. So we usually picked plots that were FEMA FEMA occupied lots. So these are lots that had flooded in the past, and then FEMA buys them because they're gonna keep getting flooded. So these lots you can't build private you can't build another home on this because it floods so much. But what you can do is build a park. So we allowed the kids to kind of design these parks in these spaces that FEMA had bought up. Um, so one of the kids found out who owned the lot and then wanted to contact them and present the plan to this person, that actually owned a lot, like how he looked all this up. I'm not sure. He developed a letter, and mom his mom and grandmother came and watched the presentation, but he was really into it. And so I think some of the kids began to take things on themselves. Um but that balance tended to focus on the community, but we really tried to make sure, Hey, you need to plan for yourself because, I mean, hopefully tomorrow, you'll have a plan. I know some people are going to be driving home early today so that they're not going to be stuck here in Atlanta if you live out of city. But I think I meant to put I think I turned this in on Tuesday, so I didn't add, like, a Snowmageddon slide, but it's really going to be important to have a plan for tomorrow, like, try not to drive. Make sure probably should get a little bit of food. I don't know how bad it's going to be, but definitely don't be on the road tomorrow. I think that would be unwise. So there's this balance of individual responsibility and community that we do, but we also, as everybody here, should try and remember that, as well. And also kind of think of the people that are homeless. Like what are they going to be experiencing tomorrow? I think we have to kind of keep that balance between community and individual always. Any other questions? Well, any other final questions? Thank you all for coming. Please be safe. Amor. I appreciate it.