This Everybody OK can you all hear me. Who said No hear me now hey Arjun You made it OK. You know the traffic OK so. It's weird to be up here with my slides but I'm going to tell you about work we've been doing I'm smack ticks. I might be in is this being streamed. But you can remove stuff. OK All right. Sorry no I was going to say Tama Bensky is retired so I'm going to try to give even comprehensible talk right now. But I want to tell you about things things that we have been studying about select ICS metrics are quite beautiful they are very very soft they're the softest crystals we know how soft Are they they're so soft that they can have discriminations which regular crystals can't have you can do with foamy stuff OK you know with foamy squishy stuff you can make it but regular hard crystals very difficult but can have discriminations and they're happy to do it. Nothing's happening because it's not on OK So this is a matic This is called a shear and texture Sharon is not a person it just means streak and the thing you know when you look at a magic is that you see these black lines in fact that's probably where the word came from the magic wind right you have these lines that come together in four and sometimes they come together into the background OK So what are you looking at so this is the set up OK. We'll do the same or is it all of old school values OK but here we have this compact fluorescent light we send the light through a polarizer we send it through an analyzer which is just a polarizer turn ninety degrees it's going to come up later because I'm going to call them different things if I called them both polarizer you would know I was talking right. And in between are some models you take a photograph so we don't know whether or no molecules there you send light through the polarizer in the analyzer and you get nothing because it's polarized light and the other polarizer is perpendicular to it the molecules However by refrigerant and as everyone knows when you have fire for it materials you get to decompose things in an ordinary and extraordinary way and what happens is that the light comes in it's polarized this way decomposes along the extraordinary ordinary directions it goes across they move at different velocities when they come back on the other side they add up but they add up wrong OK they add up wrong and so they're no longer polarized in this direction some light gets there the only time white doesn't get through is when there is no extraordinary wave or when there is no ordinary wave and that happens when the molecules happen to be parallel to the polarizer the analyzer and what you see are the black lines the black lines are all the places where the polarizer where the molecules are along the polarizer the analyzer so why do you see four you see four because there are defects and there's a defect in the middle where you don't know which way the molecules point but as you go around the defect the molecules have to rotate by two PIII So once through the polarizer one through the analyzer one through the polarizer one through the analyzer for brushes for black lines and it doesn't matter what texture you make of it rotates around by two PIII forwards or backwards you always get four brushes. I should say that the true power of typology is this is displayed right here on this picture right because you see here there are places where two brushes come together this is the picture taken with a microscope so it's like microns big right hundred probably one hundred microns you know it's at least a micron probably under one right the molecules are about and then a meter big right or as they say in Europe ten extremes OK so. This is telling me that when you go around here the molecule comes back to itself after only going through the polarizer once and the analyzer once that means that somehow the phase is indifferent to knowing whether the molecules are point up or pointing down I should have done that the other way plenty of pointing down OK And so what happens is that means that just from looking at this picture with polarizers you can tell that the the phase has an up down symmetry. Right and you're looking at this from a large late scales you don't even have to have very good off ticks to see that there's two brushes you can have higher charge brushes you don't have to just have four coming out you could have six or eight or ten or twelve and all you need to do is count the number of brushes each brush tells you that the thing is gone around gone through a motion of pi over two because one brush is per pair per polarizer the next one is analyzer so you can then count it up this would be like a a three pied effect the four pi defect the five five effect of a six by the fact so that's cool they add in fact they add just like charges if you read most books. Do calculations not only do these things add like charges they even interact like charges they interact logarithmically portion of the product of the charges in two dimensions but this is the happy exception most of the crystals are not like this most of the crystals that we know about the charges don't add they only have so neatly and they don't interact just like electrons right it is it is a myth to believe that these my gosh. I'm OK as The Kobayashi Maru I think right look look look I managed so. You go around or they say there was a Martin you were looking right at me. On the charges those. Typically add in the charges don't interact just like electrons it's much more subtle but we are led into this comfortable belief because we always show you pictures of to do the magic OK OK I'm cool OK. Now I'm not so cool it's OK So here is a symmetric and I'm going to tell you about smacked expected layered systems they're like they have layers of like ogres you have these layers I'm going to describe the layers the following way I'm going to say that there's a field five you can think of it as a potential field like an electric potential and I'm going to say that potentials are where the layers are there was one way or fight was a fight was two way you know how cool this is because five equals A In five zero don't intersect. Right they're not the same point and so unless fi is six which will be but most of the time it doesn't intersect and you have these nice and cool potential surfaces you could write the density of symmetric I don't know why it's doing that. OK you guys know one. Of them. Better. Better fix it OK just in case. G.'s. But with this. Another way. Of time the blog thing. You know I'm. Looking to game. The system Hear hear. OK Great OK so. You can write down the density you can write down the normal to the surface because you know the grad five is perpendicular to the Echo potential services because we teach that electrostatics also and you can write out energy go ahead rate of energy OK The Energy tells you that the layers want to be equally spaced this is the spacing and they don't want to bed. Now I'm not really that fascinated by energies All right there's a theorem in liquid crystals. There's a folk hero which is if you give me a phase I can find a landau theory for which it's a minimal right so you know it's not that interesting what I'm trying to understand is not the ground state of the smack that I'm trying to understand all the ground states and how the ground states are connected together. So the ground states are things where the layers are equally spaced and they don't want to bend. Now there was a theorem Brian Charron discovered this there and by reading OK because it was in some journal that most of the system read communication the mathematical physics it was from before he was born one thousand and one. So can everybody understand the theorem I couldn't he said over the theorem but this is what the theorem says the theorem says. If you have things that you would want to call smack ticks which are things with layers then things with layers can have a negative charge defect you see if I look at the normal the normal goes around by minus pi as I go around clock kind of clockwise by plus five This one is a defect with minus two pies this is minus three pies. This one is boring this is nothing this is plus high right and you can see I'm going through a set of ground states if I just look at this part here here's a ground state where the layers are equally spaced and they're all flat and here's another one here's another one you slowly go through this. It's the ground states to go from here to here. But when you're done you're in different ground states and that is why this is a top logical defect you can have this too where you have rotation by plus two piles but the theorem says you can't keep going this way you can't have plus two pods you can't have plus three pot you can't have plus four but none of it sorry you can't plus three five you can apply for pi plus two pies All right so what's weird is you can't go positive but you can go as negative as you like you can keep going down. Now this is problematic because most of us learn about top logical defects by reading this paper by Maman. Reviews a modern physics article an excellent article which you should not only download many times we should. We count downloads it is important to say so. What's the story here's a sample There's the ground state manifold here is the space of all possible ground states before it was all things that were equally spaced and flat which includes all the translations and all the rotations of that as well here's the sample it has defects places where I can't define the order you take a path you go around the sample as you measure you go around you measure what the what point in the ground state manifold you're in and it goes around a loop on the ground state manifold in the ground state manifold is interesting then the loop over here grabs the handle of the ground state manifold and once a grabs a handle it is impossible for it to unground the handle smoothly that's the whole point of typology right and the whole point is that as you go around as you let the system of smoothly by the way it's a classical physics does for you right classical equations evolve things smoothly it's impossible to unwind that handle and so you have something trapped and there's a charge. OK So let me prove put our theorem to you by drawing a picture then we never do this only teach electrostatics but we could of. Here's the X. Y. plane I'm just getting two dimensional symmetric for now two dimensional spec ticks and here's that thing five Remember echo potentials a fire going to tell me where the layers are but I mean it will draw the graph I have enough dimensions that I can plot five because the graph of this function. And now I take the level setf I call zero sea level set a good name and you get this layer and here fight was one here all the layers so you see that here you have this green mountain range and here you have. The equal height contours of the topographical map I grew up in the Midwest so this was a big revelation that you could have this but how are you Martin. Everything's minus ten right OK All right so. Those are minus three below or above sea level OK so so here you have the smack ticket here the layers and you realize that a smack Dick is nothing more than a topographical map and the cool thing about topographical maps is that you can always tell where the tops are and the bottoms you can see where the tops of mountains are and where the bottoms of lakes are because the top of the mountain is a place where every way you look is down. Is that true in the your mountain in Holland OK All right. Or it could be the bottom a lake everywhere you look is OK so. You go around in a circle you see here is a top or a bottom and when you go around it the normal rotates by plus two pi that is a plus one defect or a plus two ply defect all the mountain tops and all the weight bottoms are plus two ply defects those that are late bottom of the mountain top look exactly the same if I don't put numbers on here I just draw the contours so weight bottoms don't cancel mountaintops which my thought in fact the things that cancel them are the passes a mountain passes a place if I look at the normal the normal if I go around let's see. If I go around counterclockwise the direction the normal rotates around counterclockwise. Right so one goes around if I go around to play clock wise it goes minus two by clockwise. The passes are exactly the negative one charges. In the selected. So I was put in R.'s theorem true what happens if you take them out and try to put another mountain on top of it. Just a bigger mountain you don't get to look down on more you don't get to every direction is still down right around you you can't get to loops around you there's still just one closed contour around you because a mountain top is just a mountain and a leak underneath a lake is just a lake. And a lake on top of a mountain is also boring just a lake or just a mountain. What's interesting is bringing two mountains together and there's a theorem called the Mountain Pass there that tells you that if you try to bring two mountains together you always have a mountain pass in between and it's impossible to take these two mountains and put them right on top of each other and that's how the charge is conserved because you say this has a plus one charge and this has a plus one charge but the problem is you try to put the plus one charge in the plus one charge together you trap of minus one charge you have no choice. So you can still make a curve I could do some funny measuring I got to do it from over here I could do this and avoid the mountain pass and I could find that inside the director field rotates around by four pie but if I try to make these be the same point I can't do it because I pull in the the a pole in the mountain pass the point is if I look at Point defects in two dimensions I can't have anything bigger than plus two pi but I can have any negative one I like because I could have it would be an exceptional for a mountain range but not impossible I could have twelve mountain tops and I could have one magic pass that goes to twelve valleys between the twelve mountains right there could be one pass that would be a minus something minus twenty four five The fact. Case I could have that. But I can't add mountains to mountains you can add passes together you can't have mountains if you're a fancy pants. I'll tell you what that has to do. With is that this is a that the mountains and the lakes are the top and bottom most things you can have in a two dimensional surface you can either have something with two directions that go up or two directions that go down there's nothing more down more down pointing or more up pointing. But a pass. Is one direction goes down and one direction goes up and you can add passes together willy nilly you can't add things that are top and bottom things together but you can add passive Let me show you so here I'm going to add passes together here's a mountain pass. Right there's three directions. Here's another mountain pass each one has charge minus one half I bring them together. And I get this one a full mountain pass the charge minus minus one or I could have this would be like a mountain ridge. Right here the two mountain tops the two peaks of the ends of the ridge and I can bring these two ridges together and give myself one single mound. So I can add these things together along level sat. Right so I can add them because this is by Will some cause the value this is like life was zero or five was ten or whatever distance you like you can bring them together because they're on the same level set so that's easy addition. How do you add together. Two areas that aren't at the same height remember expected I don't have to just add together layers or at the same height I should be able to move any kind of defect together that I like. So if there's the same if they're at the same height it's easy if there are different heights of this lens at zero This means that one the stache line is a half the dash lines are always halfway or. What do you do while you create. A dislocation and the dislocation pair and dislocations are made from discriminations. And far away this looks exactly the same as it will be. Four there's layers going on here I could add extra layers on either side and I made a small little region which is a little different but it's already not local It's already it's a region that is not all at one point and that's kind of the problem I can't make everything happen and the thing will point you have this dislocation pair. As you go from here to here and so if you want to add say minus one half see there's three dark lines coming out to another minus one half but there are different values of five this is Fi equals zero This is five calls a first what you do is you make a dislocation pair and you bring them together and so look at what happened this is very strange you have these two defects which you say are charging minus one half when you add them together to tell the charge should be minus one. But if you count how many dark lines come out you say there's too many dark lines coming out this is a minus to the fact. Just by counting but in order to bring these two things together I had to make this dislocation pair I've left behind the thing. So in order to bring defects together sometimes I have to create new defects. And the new defects are in different places so that's why I can't do everything in a local way because not to bring a certain defects together I have to pop a new defect in the system so. Here's a story it's the story I just told you there's this thing called the Morse index which is the number of up directions you can go so you're at a mountain top you can only go down right there's two directions down and a lake bottom there's two directions up that to a mountain pass there's one direction up one direction down. This is called the Morse and that's telling you how many directions are up or down you can only add a Morse index thing to another one that are next door to each other you can only add a mountain top to Mountain Pass orally to a mountain pass you can't add a mountain to a lake directly. So these add together but I showed you the charge of the mountain top is plus one the charge of the bottom is plus one this is minus one of course this is also true I can add a mountaintop to a mountain pass and get nothing just like an an A plus on them I just want to get nothing. Or a mountain pass to a lake bottom and I get in the thing. So you see these alternate charge these just go down the number or up in the numbers. So in two dimensions the reason I can't have any kind of defect I like is because I can only add together things like this you can add zeros to zero the Tuesday two you can only add ones to ones. You can add mountain passes together so what's going to happen in three dimensions. You know in two dimensions I'm going to give you a rough way of explaining what we did you look at your point the fact you count the layers that come out of it Fike was there fight will ever layer you like you draw a circle route and you count how many times is this these layers intersect the circle zero times three times four times six times the charge inside is one might as the number of times intersects over two here it's one here it's minus a half here it's minus one this is a dumb way or a simple way. I don't know what the right word thing is a nice way to see that you can't have a charge that's bigger than one because I can't be negative. And so you have these layers like that to do in three D.. In three D. You have a defect and you surrounded by a sphere and then you intersect the sphere with the layers but now they're not lines they're whole services that are coming out of these points and so here is a picture of a plus one defect a point defect with charge plus one. It intersects this fear on these two circles of these two red circles here is something boring this is a nothing this is just a layer intersecting with a sphere and intersects on one red circle. This is the charge plus one or minus one. Defect to zero and see if. It is not something where it's concentric fears concentric fears don't work this way because engineers never intersect this year but this is a place where the layers go like this they're like balls appear balls on the bottom pointing up and then it goes around like in a Taurus it's a saddle but it's a three dimensional saddle multi-dimensional saddle some direction there's two indirections and one out direction or two one in direction into our direction. And so what we really. Ised is that you could take this and you could just abstract it to the spear with the red circles just like I had the circle with the intersections of the black lines here's a sphere it has two circles and then I can make a graph it turns out Hilbert did this we found out the other day and he made graphs but related to this you have a black dot for each region on the sphere and you have a red line for each boundary on the sphere and all the things you can do all the ways that surfaces can intersect a sphere correspond to every possible tree you can draw. Right and you could have a tree where you have a red circle inside a red circle that would be another line here you could have a third red circle out here that would just be a branch all possible trees and the way that you decide what the charge is you alternate the signs you had plus one minus one plus one right and that gives you the charge for this is charged plus one. Here I can show you a point charge so this is concentric fears this would be the naive thing the hedgehog where the director feels pointing out you draw the layers like that here's the point in the middle these things never intersect the sphere because they're concentric fears themselves and so their charges one because it's a point defect concentric seers. And this is the whole tree just a point nothing is coming out of it doesn't it there's one region on the sphere. Here is the one I showed you three regions charges one those that can have two different things to charge one that have different graphs so in a magic if I tell you the charges plus one the charges plus one and every plus one charges homotopic to every other possible and charge in this MC tick these two plus one charges are different you can't go from one to the other so what's cool is a symmetric then in two dimensions the selected had fewer D.. Facts in the magic in three dimensions this Mexican's more defects that the charge is enough to tell you what's going on you can have point charted and you can have even more here's one where the charges zero there are three layers there's this cone and this cone and this flat plane the charges zero that's the graph Here's one where the charges two and here's the graph notice that this has four region then this has four regions but they're connected in different ways. So the tree doesn't tell you enough the tree doesn't give you all the information nor does the charge so the effects and smack ticks are actually more subtle they actually are there's a there's a refinement of them beyond just telling me their top logical charge like in that if you can add them together Thomas shown is really good at drawing pictures but you know here you can add together two point defects that are on the same surface this is adding along level sets you can add them together. You can also add was together that are on different level sets to do that you have to make a dislocation you actually have to poke a hole in this middle surface you have to be able to connect this cone to this cone through this intermediate surface this is like five holes they're zero one two and one make you connect so I have to cut a hole. You notice that in order to do this I have to introduce a wind defect. So a weird thing about smack ticks is that in order to have selected to do anything interesting if you don't want them to be sterile you have to introduce line defects in it. And say the highs Emberg model of the X. What in the in the in a magnet in a model of a magnet you can just have point effects you don't have to have one that you want to have wind effects in the Maddux can have them but a smacked it forces you to have it if you want this method to do anything interesting it has to have wind effect so you can have a boring smack dick which it stays and does. And it does or you could have one that stain Amec with a defect mix around but then you have port wine defect and so it really requires us to classify wine the fat and we did and it's a little more complicated but not a lot more complicated is that instead of wrapping a sphere around the line you wrap a cylinder around the Y. which means you can have one region and one boundary you could have a graph like this so it's a it's a it's not a tree it's a something with one loop and there's different graphs it's interesting but not that interesting I mean it's interesting is interesting it's come do it to do it completely you have to have it it also means that even if you think that you have a nice oriented smack tick where the layers all with where the where the directions of the layers are all perfectly well defined you don't have the cinematic symmetry you are forced to have half charged effects if you want to have any dynamic. So for instance here's an experiment. If you have a two D. smack tick a regular to be smacked at. You have all the Bernard convection cells so you have these roles in the Rolls or go in opposite directions next to each other that's a regular to be symmetric because you can bend those things around and you can have a half charged effect but if you had lines or defects that came from if you had stripes that were in a coup itself so you have an inner cylinder and outer cylinder those roles are always going in the same direction they can't bend around and turn around so rolls in a coup at solved are going to be different than their dynamics and going to be very different than roles in say a road Benard convection cells. So. By. You next speaker you know. All right so. I'm going to give you an application of what we did right so here's this very old picture it's in French it makes it even harder to read OK but this is a picture of a. A defect in a smack tic it's actually a screw dislocation and a smack tick it connects layers around and he woke away and Claymont pointed out that you can actually decompose it into to. Discrimination. To discrimination was the charge one half because as you go around right. I wish I had a boy I'm not going to deface your thing that but you have you have something like this here the preview points and here you have the layers and then you rotate it and you go around this way. And that gives you the structure and here these two discrimination lines but the charge of both those this commission lines is plus a half and you know anybody who grew up in the area that I grew up knows that dislocations are not made out of discriminations of the same charge but this locations are made out of discrimination dipoles So here you have a plus a what a plus what happened in minus one half discrimination making dislocation. But here I have two plus a halves making a dislocation and we never stand how to connect those things together in fact I remember city enough and I had the amp room once it wasn't down it was hot with the bed and Brian Chan and Gary thousand and are we convinced ourselves as a possible way but we were wrong but it was because we were in Princeton OK It turns out there's a way to do it you can do it but to do it you have to squish it and make this plus one have to factor into a pair with a minus one have to figure and I know this picture is completely incomprehensible Let me show you a different picture. Here on the top I have something that looks like plus one half goes around the director rotates around by pi on the bottom it's something where the director rotates around by minus Pod. And in a magic These are exactly the same thing in a magic rotating by Plus pyro to my mind aspire the same thing in three dimensions because you can escape into the third dimension. I remind you that that's true so here is the magic gravity manifold R.P. two Here is a structure where all the molecules are rotating around this is plus one half now I smoothly deformed the texture and they're rotating up into the X. into the Z. direction and I come back around and now I have a path that still goes from this point to this point that used to go around this equator the center the equator now go to that end of the equator and they have a minus one half show you again you go from plus one half to minus one half smoothly. In a magic you can't do that must make them in a smack tick you have to do it at a point. Because can't do that thing of rotating out into the third dimension you can go from my IF THEY HAVE TO plus a half but you have to do it at a single point where you just add this like boat to the set of layers and quite abruptly It means that a cover experimentalists could prepare a cell with a plus one half the fact on one side and a minus one half defect on the other side you know you draw down to the surface put a smack tick in there and they'll be a wind effect that connects them with a point City on it they should be able to move right by doing something clever I don't know how you could move it right you do something some kind of for recess you do you something you come up with something clever OK you know you you rotate it you put seven up in the space shuttle I'm sure that we are no spatial if you send it to the space station is there still a space station. One of just follow the sky right let me know. In a space it should just fall out of the sky. Yeah no no there was a space station they thought of the sky no one was in it because of the way it was the satellite was in it OK it was orbiting the Earth though. So let me tell you where we're going so you know this classification of defects point defects is hard because the math. Partly because you could write down what you're supposed to do but no one's ever calculated it right and we don't know how to calculate things so we have to make up our own things but the problem is or the problem is how do you cross a five defects in general and look at crystals so they're pneumatic everyone knows how do Magic's their smack ticks I think we kind of have to handle and smacked it but the real challenge is not selected the real challenge is called. Let me tell you about Lisa trans work and with that Lisa Tran just defended her thesis that she's Dr trained so we're going to Bryn Mawr any year so she's professor trained OK she made this she made this in a laboratory OK this is not a simulation this is a coast there are shelf there's a shell there's water on the inside and there's water on the outside there's some delicious surfactant to hold the whole thing together and in between it's Coast Eric with the crystal and the beauty of the surf act it is now it is a surf act and hold the things together there surfactant actually changes the anchoring direction of the molecules so I'll remind you what to call a stereo because this is a soft matter school so you guys should all know right coast to coast Erik's or systems where the molecules rotate to go around. And helix the helix Lee. It turns out the surfactant like that for the molecules to be parallel pandered to perpendicular to the surface. Revenue you a service doesn't work how can I be perpendicular to the sky and also do this. So I can. So what it does it does this good and then the. Right it makes these very fast motions through the rotation so it manages to rotate but you can change how much it rotates by changing how much the fact that there is by change you is there a fact in concentration you can change how hard it is to rotate and how hard how how how and phatic likes to point normal to the surface. And because there's water on the outside Lisa just changes it by washing away surfactant and here the surfactants going away you have straight stripes and then when it's all done this or fact is gone and the molecules actually tangent to the surface now those are pretty pictures right we did this with the recent Lopez Leon. But. I guess a this one to go. Ahead I don't know where Peter is. With that. Three three minute. Well let's just go very pretty We don't have any idea this takes days to unwind or hours we have no idea why it organise themselves so that we can look at it so nicely but every last one of them do right we start them they start in some random direction and it rotates so we can watch it right as not thermal because we turn the light off in between pictures we don't think so right could be gravity. Which is why we have to do it up in the space. But I want to show you a picture I can find. No I can't find it right now it's OK Let me just tell you what this is good for. So Lisa working with Martin Haas figured out. That in fact the surf acted does not uniformly smear itself across the surface of the surf act it actually face separates and goes with the straight stuff. And she knew that by putting forth a sheaf Leslie labeled some of the some of the scene for us and labeled the surfactant you could see where it's at but then what she did is she took coal oil it's interesting that they're right now they're not interesting they're probably you know silica but they could be interesting they could be cadmium selenite quantum dots right. She functionalize them and surfactant and then they sat on the layers and you can cross-link them you can cross-link them in place so you can actually stop this pattern whatever you want because these are all equilibrium or quasi equilibrium you could stop right now you could wash in wash out the old washing the noose or fact and that has quantum dots on it. And then you can put a rise in place so you can make patterns you can make resonators is our hope. To order you can have lots of little resonators if you wait long enough you can have one giant resonator OK so we can actually now make patterns structures and we have control over the pattern we even understand how to get them I should say this is to reset the main point to reset makes this point quite eloquently the beauty about shells compared to drops is that a shell is the best thing you can do to get a fairly suspended surface because you can control the inside anchoring and the outside a Korean separately and we can do that because we can change is affecting concentration on the outside dynamically we can set the concentration on the inside when we start and then we can use salt to swell the whole shell which changes the concentration on the inside so we can change everything we can change the inside on the outside there. Also a temperature dependence which Teresa's group discovered So there's many knobs you can turn to actually change what the patterns are you can have these patterns that are hexagons and pentagons you can have more complicated patterns if you mess with the insides. I'm going to leave you with pictures of my three collaborators hell how. Each and and Thomas shown is about to leave us in the breast stuff so thank you for attention.