Our presenter is Pamela longer Bartie distinguished professor at the Welsh School of Art and Design at Georgia State Pam is a prolific artist and activist who has had over forty solo exhibitions and sixty five groups exhibitions and galleries and museums around the world in locations including the United States China Italy Spain Japan and many others I had the pleasure of meeting Pam just months after first arriving in Atlanta and I've seen her work in a number of venues I was struck initially by her stunning and a theory of paintings which represent diverse materials and textures and I continue to be intrigued by the range of her work at the intersections of art science and nature more recently I've had the opportunity to see some of her projects related to issues of sustainability and they call A-G. purse cultures and installations which often archive the junk that she's found on the beaches around the world have a haunting and urgent quality representing these objects as simultaneously arbitrary nostalgic and beautiful this work part of the Drifters project that she stablished in two thousand and six addresses global plastic pollution and the changing ocean Pym began this project after encountering the mountainous piles of plastic the ocean was bringing to shore in remote beaches in Hawaii and the project has led her to collaboration's in Atlanta China Greece Monaco Alaska Panama the list goes on and her work has been featured in National Geographic and also on the cover of Sierra magazine working solo or with communities has made scores of interventions cleaning beaches of plastic all over the world removing thousands of pounds of material from the natural environment and re situating it within the cultural context I've given just a very brief synopsis to introduce her work and there is so much more to know. So please join me in welcoming Pam love of art. Thank you Naren thank you for the hearty crowd who is skipping the rejuvenation bar I know it's happening today so it's really nice to be here because I feel like we are sister entities just right down the road and. Can kind of begin a more maybe fruitful and verdant collaboration I would love that. A real lowering house lights is that possible OK it will make the slideshow better. So I just got back from an amazing place in Monaco which had. One of our films was just premiered there at the Blue Ocean Film Festival and conservation summit and it was shown at the oceanographic Museum which is a cathedral to the ocean and. It also focuses on art and science and for me that this sort of triangulation between art and science and activism is the heart of my work so to begin the ocean where for me I feel like this is. The most urgent and pressing reality that we're facing right now the ocean is not only the driver of climate on this planet it isn't truly the circulatory system and. I believe it's also the sort of consciousness of the planet it's where life started on this planet and it's to sum total of all the creatures that have ever lived in there and evolve from there and continue to and right now there's just serious serious problems with the sea so my dad was an ocean lifeguard my mother was a Delaware swimming and diving state champion and I came back to a connection with the ocean and I. I had to get it back in my life because it was missing being landlocked here in Atlanta and decided in two thousand and six that I was going to learn how to serve and it simultaneously launched this whole project which was now called The Drifters project. So this talk really though is about time and it's about a different time frame than we used to so our in the mid eighty's worked for a paleontologist called Jack Horner who's MacArthur fellow Princeton distinguished alumni and he we had a dinosaur dig at this location and this location isn't showed in Montana but this was the Eastern at Lanigan beach coast of. The World in eighty million years ago so to think about time in that different time of that type of a time frame and geologic time scale was an extremely important and distinctive. Turning point in my life so in my twenty's I started working with him and I started thinking about time on a different scale so the dinosaurs that were fossilized here eighty million years ago were thirty foot had restores along with some other species but they were a large ground nesting dinosaur that was fossilized in an event very similar to Pompei So a volcanic ash fall basically froze or cooked. The creatures in situ what they were doing at that time in their life so they were actually evidence this became the evidence for. Parental care by dinosaurs of the babies so they had not only new hatched hatchlings they had year Langs and they had eggs all in the same nest which meant the babies stuck around in the mother was caring for them. Which made them much more like modern day. Flamingos essentially then they are modern day reptiles So my job was to do drawings and and this was soon prior to photoshop and so a lot of scientific illustration. Based on artists making composites and so for instance this aid did not exist we did it based on projecting the curves and working with Jack Horner with you know this the size and shape of that the egg needed to be. And then this big came published in Scientific American and it made me realize that a lot of what we know and understand as science is conjecture and it's based on our best guess at the time and so you know science is an evolving paradigm and more and more I'm finding that artists have a voice because we have very similar research methodology as. We look and study things very hard for extended periods of time and that I'm finding now at this stage in the game which I think is you know a late stage in the game but that scientists and artists are joining forces in a way that we haven't really in our lifetime to address the most critical climate issues of the planet. So back to my own artwork I. Did those drawings for work but I had a much more expressive. Style for my my personal work and I was working with I guess I should have realized it was going to start surfing at some point when I started making my paintings look like surf books but I was working with copper and prettiness to function as a kind of stand in for wild nature so those things would do their chemical interactions and then I would come in with imagery and it would basically seal that surface it was like paving over the natural world in the way that you know human. Culture does so this was about that. Again that Di did teach geologic time and that the ice age would have remembered a time when it was tropical. This is a much more recent painting that's similar materials but you know basically. Fifteen years later. And I. Work with this kind of collision now of these natural materials and. For me the painting is actually a very important almost antidote to the Drifters work the plastic work which I talk primarily about. Because I can always is unsure of the outcome in these that you know nature's going to be fine and that the rainbows will come out and humans will probably be relegated to caves and trying to scrap around for insects it's. OK But back to the idea of the dinosaurs so we are now in a a point in the human evolution of history where you know this fossil sunlight essentially which created the life on Earth which is now creating these vast deposits of oil which are now being depleted are the evidence that we are in the you know the later stages of the industrial petrochemical world that we live in and. If we think about that and we think about this beautiful graphic as a time frame of the history of the earth itself. You know all of these layers. Basically add up to the oil that we are now running through and the whole US enough of which is this last little slice of the spiral here is the point in history in which all human evolution has occurred. But we are now at the end of that point so the A group called the. Commission for the watch when you're used to your partners a period that included the place the scene and the whole of scene. Those are a group of scientists who determine the geologic age of the earth and they've now determined that in two thousand and sixteen we are ending the whole the same era and we're entering a new one called Anthropocene in the Anthropocene is literally. The. Human impact on the planet which will be evident in the geologic record and for me this is absolutely critical because I see plastic as the physical marker of the Anthropocene So we will see this in future layers and I have already found fragments of plastic that are vulcanized they are becoming a new composite with stones and rocks as they pass by the south point of Hawaii and become fused with lava they are being Reese wallowed by the caves as these caves collapsed in earthquakes so I'll talk about that more later. But when did this word ocean plastic become part of our vocabulary for me that was in two thousand and six when I was at the south point of the big island of Hawaii and now it's you know become something that people can put as a product label. On you know a. Common hand soap you can buy a target. So. As this. You know fossil field climate change. Is basically changing the entire surface of the Arctic and melting it and causing these creatures which live there to be under extreme distress and we are now opening up the shipping channels that are going to pass through this place and exploited even more we find the plastic has already made it there before us so you know there's there's something so pivotal book about this moment to be alive that I think there's nothing really more urgent than seeing the linkages between all these things and acting upon them. So back to the beginning of my story I was visiting Hawaii I used to go there a lot in the ninety's and I went back in two thousand and five and I was going to an artist colony that's right tip of the big island here at a place called South Point and when I found that place. I I was just magnetically drawn there I knew I wanted to see the face of the Pacific Ocean and what that looked like and even though my you know my little cabin was up here I just spent all my time down there. And when you go to the Syria and you see pictures from Google and you see what the big looks like it's not what you imagine of Hawaii's big island has twenty six microclimates this part looks more like Montana it's very barren it's dusty it's dry it's cattle country what you're looking at are trails for livestock and there's really not much human habitation there. Except when you walk the beach so this was the very first image that I saw walking around that point and you know as an artist I was kind of shocked and like what is that what are these colors I could imagine them being there and then I was as I got closer I thought well my God Is this a dump and then I realise no this is actually being vomited out of the ocean is not dumped by humans there and this was within that first image that I saw and it was just one of those moments where your life changes and I realise that this ocean is full of plastic and it's now being vomited out onto the beaches remote beaches all over the world and to see the symbol of this toilet seat was just like the driving metaphor for how we see the ocean itself and the natural world. So I set up a field camp and I started going down there by myself for several years and documenting photographically at first and then literally cleaning the beaches with as much as I could take out but I started to feel like I was being communicated with the ocean by the plastic itself the materials ever on making and this was one of the first photographs I took and this is a drift net which I'll talk more about in a moment but it's it's more than that it's a net ball meaning that it's a it's a tangle meant of nets that the ocean is put together and to me it was so much like a. A sleeping corpse I could even see the head of the Prost arms that it just felt like this is a sign of contact of a message that I need to follow up on so this is a bigger netball you can see the scale of it it's about forty feet long. The some of the ropes in there are disfigured around it actually are our nets that are cut loose and left adrift so they continue fishing and they are completely. Down the poor all they are and tangling and killing lots of species that are not being harvested and you know they wait times physically. This is what the problem is they are part of a large scale. Way of looking at the ocean as a kind of endless feed trough and so we been thinking about this as the sort of Bountiful plenty that is going to be endless and go on forever and these are all unintended caption I'm sorry for these pictures are extremely painful for me to look at but Nets and long lines. And here for sushi I mean this is the this is the. Tune of factory fishing that is taking out one of the biggest predators who literally swim the entire Pacific Ocean and an albatross and you know they're there catching the tuna but these there are so many albatross that are also caught in these lines which can be sixty miles long of baited hooks. And I think the scale of that is something that we're not aware of unless you're on the ground and looking at it or part of the industry itself so to think about this is you know this sort of like one catch one day's haul on the ship. Is just a wrong headed way to think about the future of the planet. So I wanted to do something first of all with these nets and I thought well I'm going to I've got to get them back out of here and so I would just cut them and carry them it's about three miles back to the vehicles and it's. A hot and dry and windy place and I made. The first image which was a drift net so adrift web so it was like a combination of a spider web as a predatory tool with the giraffe net but also to talk about the connection of. The cycle of life in the sort of web of interconnectedness of the planet and I've made. A number of them there's actually one up in the airport right now. And the other thing that our earlier in endless quantities are are all of the plastic household objects of our life so this was you know again one of these photographs where I felt like I was entering a crime scene and I had to document that material stuff that we use every day so you know I was sort of born into the plastic era you know this was. How you had your birthday parties and your dinner parties and. I was born in fifty eight plastic became. You know Kershaw Lee widespread in the fifty's. Was invented in the thirty's so it's really literally sixty years that we've done this to the ocean that's a shocking thing to imagine and what that is is that there are these large jar systems which are circulating currents Here's a little Hawaiian right here this is what's called the North Pacific subtropical gyres and can see the directions of those currents and so all of the stuff that. Landed on that point was on its way to the jar where it's not an island per se but it's a vast vast area when I started this in two thousand and six they were describing it as the size of the state of Texas then it became double the size of the state of Texas then it became the size of the continental United States and now we know there is one in every major oceanic jar system and and there are six of ones in all the minor ones as well so there's eleven total. And I do. Sided I've got to get this material back and just show people what was happening there so those objects that come out of the things those the bags and the points that I was cleaning. I started to look at as these strange poetic. Cultural artifacts and there was no way to really. Talk about them except to let them be so I started to make portraits of them and and the strange kinds of messages that were coming from this material which had been changed by it's travel across the ocean. And one of the first things I found that really convinced me that I was dealing with something that was going to be a long term project was I found these two pieces of plastic at Southpoint and they were near each other and so what is this that we're looking at are we looking at you know the Iraq war toys set her was just an army man that got somehow mixed up and put next to a child's Zuda plastic animals that you know those were questions I had but the point to me was that. In two thousand and six was the height of the the second Gulf War And here we are having the acculturation of children through plastic toys which are in themselves made of of oil So war is being promoted. A war against oral. Against losing oil essentially is being promoted through the toys that are. Given to children and not only that these were amputees. I found so many firearms as well it's very interesting this one's particularly good it says Universal. And then other objects which are more particular like for me that the bubble gum is a kind of a two prong double whammy because it's a stir flax come. And I'm a surfer and it also is talking about my main addiction to plastic which is the gum. Gum attic and gum is made of plastic. And I wanted I need to twelve step program to get off of it. So. I saw it like I've got to make a sign and you know this is one of the first pieces I made and it uses the idea of the color blind in this chart. An hour and a certain Rebus formation of the word Dead Sea because I don't think we see the plastic I think it's that we don't see it for what it is it's so ubiquitous it's around us at all times and it's also selling itself to us through this color. Then I thought well I'm it's actually a mirror of ourselves because these are things that we use every day so many cones and toothbrushes and just you know these materials that are our pictures of us and you see the top is all these umbrella lanterns so I made these very large scale black mirrors and no sooner had I finished the first one and then the Deepwater Horizon disaster occurred so that the black became very significant to me as the most representative color of plastic for its relationship to oil. I made pieces that referenced the scientific structure of plastic and the reason that it's. So dangerous to humans and to up to all animal bodies and fish and you know basically the entire living part of the planet is that it is an organic compound it is based on a hydrogen molecule and when the plasticizers that go into the make the plastic is different you know qualities transparent hard whatever color it is those things leach out of the material into the surrounding water and if that water is your water bottle that's what you're drinking and those things act in our bodies like estrogen so. Endocrine disruptors. They are changing not only the creatures of the planet for instance some sea creatures like sea cucumbers and starfish started out as female and then a natural part of the progression is to turn now and they never do so they're not reproducing at the same rate in our bodies it is now been linked to A.D.H. D. all Simers obesity breast cancer lower testosterone in males and a particularly heinous. Disease a sort of genital birth defect called hyperspeed E.O. where babies are born with the Pew research coming out the side of the penis instead of the center so they have to operation from birth. They're prepared with plastic This is coming from their mother's bloodstream. But for me really like I'm Ari I feel like. My primary concern is with the the sea and the creatures of the sea who are also feeling this impact and so these are all lighters that were recovered from albatross nests on Midway So that means these four hundred ninety lighters were. Brought to the. Nast by the mother or father albatross these birds are extraordinary there have seven foot wings fans they fly for three weeks without stopping up into the Arctic Circle which brings them directly over that gyre and they dip down in and pick up food squid crabs you know normal things only now a large majority of what they bring back is plastic and you can see right here this is Mother Albatross is vomiting a lighter to her baby so what happens of course of this is the pictures that you've probably seen a million of. The babies die with their stomachs full of plastic so they're completely impacted with plastic. And this is a crime against nature. I also started to use the pieces to talk about another concept which I ran into when I was shopping at Trader Joe's now I sort of like Trader Joe's because it reminds me of lying California but I kind of hate Trader Joes too because they have all their produce wrapped in plastic they do have good prices on wine and they have nice flowers but all together I have a lot of problems with them and one of them is their mentality about certain things so one of their little cute handwritten signs in the in the Trader Joe's on. In Buckhead said how can we continue to offer so much seafood at such incredibly low prices economies of scale and they had a picture of a kid fish and I started thinking about that word economies of scale it's actually a marketing term and it's a marketing term that's now been applied to the ocean and what it means is that you know the more volume that you can produce the the the lower price per unit for each thing so it literally has been you know the way that we have continued to exploit the world's oceans and now we know just from two thousand and ten the consensus of marine life has has represented that there are ninety percent depletion of the top predatory species in the ocean which of sharks tuna swordfish and of the large bill fish so those are the top of the food chain once you start losing those here you're really looking at a collapsing ecosystem. So I took this piece which is also plan words because the idea of scale but it goes it's twenty feet long it goes from a single styrofoam ball found in a sea cave in Greece up to that fifteen pound net float which was found in Alaska. And each one of these this is. On an interactive Web site where you can learn the. Where it was found what it is and you know some facts about the different kinds of production that it represents. Since two thousand and five of been working in Catalonia in Greece which is I mean not to those of five two thousand and eleven for five years and Catalonia is an amazing island that is part of the Ionian Sea So this is in the. Western part of Greece and the other Ionian Islands are core through with a car and another larger Michael's on type of Catalonia is the biggest and it is an extraordinary island it's ringed by sea caves and I've been. Working there on the ground in a kind of. Community based effort cleaning the sea caves. Mobilizing the Naval Academy children and adults the adventure community there's a lot of kayakers and and and and divers and whatnot with this idea of plastic free island and that was the film that we showed in Monaco just a week ago. And I have just a brief clip I'll show you this the first part of it because this was kind of an extraordinary. Place that we. Cleaned in two thousand a lot in two thousand and twelve I discovered it in two thousand and eleven but I want to just play the first five minutes of the film because you can see of see what is happening there so this film was what we showed in Monaco this is actually the an earlier version that was a sketch loops and I want to do that I wanted to. Do full screen OK. And I think the sound is going to be on please. Worst way to. Do. It. Was to go where. There was. Rays shining wires. You know. Everything I. Did. And. Then I started. They. Hear you. Here and they. Do it. My razor is. The first. Three is still a new. Experience we were only wireshark a measure of a. Leader and you're. Just. Trying. To. Write. A. Few things. Only. Bearly three was getting. Rid of excess believe plastics back in the city as i recently. Read. In a river. And I just. Thought that. This is. This is this. For you our. Bases for life. Is this where is a greater way or saw. The most. Amazing beautiful I was a scientist I see a mess like. This. Where. This. Whoops. OK. So that's that's just the beginning of the thirty minute. Film and. Sorry. Effect where it was. So. You know the primary material that was was in the cave really was started from and. The thing about the star from I think that's really critical is that. First of all it's still being used. For food packaging all over the world it is a known carcinogen it's starring And the thing that's particular about Greece is that they basically use these star phone containers for their bait and they no longer have like these giant fish you hold to put the cash you know they're fishing with nets that have eyes to stick so you know this is we're looking at a kind of an advanced overfished location there. And yet this very fisherman I've been told by other fishermen that they're throwing the plastic star from containers right into the ocean and that's why they're so present there it's everywhere and yet what the way nature does is makes it looks incredibly interesting and most people don't even see it because it looks like rocks or coral so we took almost two thousand pieces of. Star from out of the cave. And returned the following year with students and we were able to make with clean up that we mobilized hundreds of people on the island this large. Or a Borroughs which is actually you know a very old symbol the snake eating its tail which Interesting enough is how the scientist who discovered the structure of. The carbon molecule had a vision about that that was snake was spiraling around a bit on his tail and so he saw he saw that it had to be a ring shape structure but the truth of the aura Borroughs is that it also is something in nature and snakes when they're under stress will actually eat their own tails as well octopi eat their own arms and so. You know it's like to me it's another symbol that's beyond it's like a spooky or in reality then it is even in the thought logy. And this piece became a moving sculpture that was part of a performance and it was shown in the center square. And then moved last summer to the good laundress Museum of Natural History and by the time it got there it had died and it got kind of crushed along the way and it was more like the skin of the stick now so this was the poster or bore us. And the glamorous museum show was really interesting because we collaborated with a number of the scientists who are studying the marine environment there. This is of no other piece I mean I'm a skip over but the and most interesting part for me was that there are were existing dire RAM is in this museum and so I was able to do interventions in those diaries and this meaning that I placed this plastic insitu around the creature set in the ways that they're affected and this was plastic that came directly from that island of California. This is a leatherback sea turtle the other one is a Mediterranean monk seal and then my favorite thing that I got to do was they actually have a triceratops and they let me make a styrofoam landscape underneath him and being underneath the ribs of that triceratops really was like being in a cave so it sort of became like the cave again and brought that whole. Thing full cycle so I have a couple more things I could talk about or we could stop here and have questions it's I think it's about five to twelve. But your preference. What I have is Panama with the queen our meal and leatherback sea turtles when I see that OK I was there in Panama this is the most remote part of Panama it's on the very border with Colombia and it is. Basically like the headquarters of the narco trafficking areas very remote very dangerous place once you get outside of their village which is absolutely beautiful it's the Crimean Jala are an indigenous peoples that are autonomous they own the land they have their own laws. However that means also that they have no municipal facilities from the government of Panama there's no water there's no electricity there's no sewage system so when you're there you are living in these beasts that Chuck's and because of that it isn't one of the major leatherette sea turtle nesting sites in the world. And they have every year a sea turtle Festival which is basically some how some people you know twenty people maybe find out about this in are able to make their way there it's really hard to get there you have to take two planes and then you know a boat two boats and a plane and you you essentially are in a place that there are no roads going to this so that you can't drive there you have to come by this other route and they have they're the most beautiful people there are just absolutely lovely their culture they make these incredible clothing This is how the women dress and they make the clothing that called mole eyes which just means clothing but they're basically like an a living cultural adaptation of symbology and you know they they change so they have you know it's not just traditional patterns there are these are artists these women are artists and they'd be their arms and legs as you can see and she would. Came a good friend of mine and so I was brought there to work with the plastic because they have some of the most inundated beaches in the world and my idea was that here's a group of women artists it's extremely hard to get materials to them. And yet they have all this plastic so I sort of showed them how the plastic could be a like an art material and one of the other things that happened you saw that picture of the sea turtle he doesn't belong here he's almost you know he's like one hundred yards from the beach and he you know if they weigh a thousand to two thousand pounds so it's incredibly strenuous for them to come on land and to lay their eggs and it's not a he it's actually a she but they got confused by these you know a well meaning NGO had given them for the first time during the winter solar lights and so the lights were now shining out in the village and therefore attracting the sea turtles to come on land because they don't. They don't know what a light is and the lightest thing that they usually see is the breaking waves and that's what they go to so then be in confusion after they've you know strained and laid these eggs nests and covered the nests you see the lights and they started walking the actually made it all the way into the village on going down the little dirt road to the village and you know how do you move it that two thousand pound turtle it's really difficult so it was a disaster and it happened while I was there so that the project became even more. You know like in the best possible way like that but it helped those wildlife because what we did was we took these big five gallon plastic drums that were all over the ocean. Beach and made these like covers for them in the the women actually decorated thems because they are creative and they like things to look interesting and colorful and so we just drilled pieces of plastic and attach them to this like cover so that they would look good in the daytime and please the women and the rest of the village and then do a function at night. Just to block the light. So it was kind of a conservation when for the turtles It was an engagement the women were so cool and you know they don't even speak Spanish they speak their own language so this is Amanda who was a Fulbright scholar and she'd been living there for eight months and she had learned the language and so she was able to be the interpreter and so you know the lights became a real protection and then the women interested in this material had formed a plastic co-op. To use the material you know which I I forgot I didn't put a picture of the way the beaches look but they are horrendous and then from all this plastic that I picked up there I made this image which. Became the cover of Sierra magazine and. They really wanted to use an iconic image that. Showed. You know some sort of relationship between the human and the plastic and I said I want the plastic to look back you know I made images in my paintings before of these sort of like isolated eyes and so they said what about the most iconic image of eyes that exists. To anybody recognize yeah so it's the it's a National Geographic photograph by a public NO NO. I can't remember his name right now but the Afghanistan girl who strangely enough someone described her as. Having the most see green eyes. And this such a haunted look and you know you can see by the materials there that most of the things were actually toys. For children and there's one little thing in there that. You know it's just it is not a close up so I can't show you but. It's sort of like a perversion of the future to me and so I had I wanted to use those things and I you know for me it was just became them again the most. We statement about that experience in Panama. And seeing the children and a lot of them actually find their toys on the beach that's where they go shopping. And and most of these toys are sort of marketed towards children and a lot of them specifically towards girls so. I think that's maybe we're all stop in case anybody has any questions and I know. There must be some. Ideas or. Thoughts you might have. Or us depressed if you found a hard subject but you know I don't know I am not actually at all I'm mobilized and motivated because when I started this in two thousand and six was by myself. Felt like I was completely by myself and then year after year you know when I decided just to hard nobody care and I can't do this another time I can't bend over for the millionth time. Suddenly there were more and more people doing it and now it's literally a movement it is a global movement and there are there's so much activation happening all over the world and. I think we have about five minutes to figure it out but to me I'm hopeful I'm really hopeful because you know there I can just see the change that's happened in the ten years that I've been working on this and you know it's extraordinary. Somewhere in. Her. Size. You know. Where. You. Are. Or. And so. You. Know. It is massive and you know that it's a problem that you know but but the thing is I feel like there's something that every single person can do we do every day we make decisions like. Towards or away from plastic in every single move we make do you bring your own baggage you bring a plastic bag do you forget those bags in the car and then make yourself walk the groceries out that's how I train myself to not forget them you know. Do you buy the product in a glass jar or the plastic bottle in matter if you like the other one better you know I think all those things are little steps and I think once people realize and I'm so sad there's not like a ton of students here because this is everything they need to know they need to know that they're getting poisoned every drop of water that they drink out of those plastic bottles it's at seventy degrees those chemicals leach into those bottles and usually you know I speak a lot in a lot of places and usually at that point when you see like the seventy degree things and you know there's always people in the room and I say I'm sorry I'm calling you out but I care about the fact that this is happening to you knew you don't know it and so you know literally I see people crying I see people come up to me and they're just like you can tell their faces they have been impacted tremendously by the information and I think it's we're in an Occupy moment all all it's going to take is is you know just basically that the knowledge to spread and then people will stand up in droves and I think it will be like we're not accepting this anymore and once the faucet gets turned off on land. Things can start to address the other part of the problem it is an enormous problem and it seems overwhelming but I personally ten years into it I'm more energized than I ever have been. So. Any other thoughts.