The fall of the end of the working group on race and racism and contemporary biomedicine which were kind of shortening to race biomed dot org to make it easier for you guys to follow up and find out what we're up to we are an interdisciplinary group of scholars across biomedical engineering biological sciences the liberal arts social sciences and trying to work together on issues about how race and racism impact our health impact by medical research we received our start up funding from the Georgia Tech Provost a couple of years ago and now we're fortunate to have ongoing support from the College of Liberal Arts here at Georgia Tech as well as the college of Sciences coming together but our group actually incorporates far beyond that so we have a folks that were involved from Emory from Spelman from Agnes Scott and elsewhere and so if these are issues that you would like to continue to talk about in a more research focused way please look at our Web site raised by my dot org and get in touch to find out how you can get more involved so my name is AM public I don't think I said I'm in literature media and communication here at Georgia Tech but now I will pass it on to my capable kopi I am moderator. All right thank you very much and thank you all for coming out in the hope of a great event I'm going to step out the way quickly so the way this will happen is that we have first our three invited speakers for a brief period so you can understand the perspective with which they are approaching this issue and then after that will come together and have a moderated discussion with Q. and A from the audience and among the panelists All right so our first speaker is Dr Evelyn Patterson who comes to us from Vanderbilt University we met about a year ago when we all went to Vanderbilt for a wonderful. Symposium on U.S. health in the south but turned over to Evelyn. Thank. You. Wireless Keyboard. Still fancy. I'm just kidding I'm not really here and so I represent the nerd of the group I actually prepare some powerpoint presentation and hopefully you'll get something out of that for the most part my work is situated in looking at correctional populations and so by that I mean populations under the supervision of the criminal justice system so parole populations populations on probation people who are actually incarcerated whether it be in jail or prison. And also looking at the actual impact of people who are being imprisoned or whatever under that supervision and how it cascades across those individuals and families and communities and so today I'm focusing on for meal incarceration by familial incarceration I mean that you have an immediate family member who is incarcerated or it so move on and tell you a little bit of background about other studies that have looked at a million course aeration for the most part the bulk of the work has been done with the status called the fragile families and so by definition you have to have a fragile family which is defined as having a child basically out of wedlock and so fragile family there we go that's nice for it. But there are some limitations with thinking about it that way or at least studying only people who constitute how you define a fragile family first of all families are different shapes and sizes so we could be thinking about just the nuclear family or your immediate family or we could be thinking about extended family but think about household. Where maybe you have a grandparent that lives in the household or an uncle or not that is not considered at all right but going back to this in terms of so you sort of look at the fragile families it means that they're only looking at women who have children who also are not married but certainly there are other types of people who experience from Moon Carse aeration right I'm sure there are people who might have siblings incarcerated or who might have a father incarcerated and so that's one of the big limitations of prior work. The work that I'm doing right now uses a data set called The national survey of American life and it is great because well for one we are not just looking at fragile families and to well I'm using it and so I just makes a great OK. So one of the other things that I sort of want to bring to the table is that well for one when we think about incarceration in general images come to our mind right or if we think about crime anything like that certainly there are just images that pop up right away so if I say OK there's somebody who just committed a crime what comes to mind. As a shot some I'm really informal. Robbery OK so somebody commit a robbery what do they look like they're male All right sounds good to me or anything else early twenty's that sounds good to our right early twenty's male. The else. Who what army. Aren't OK that makes us we armed make sense or you can have really like big arms. Race ethnicity thing like that. Dark MALE All right dark male art so we're looking for dark mellow mid twenty's who has big arms and his arm. Right. So we have these sort of stereotypes that have gone on for many many many centuries in terms of the kernel ization of certain groups of people to the degree that we in some ways so consciously and doesn't matter what color you are or what gender you are you cetera somehow connect race and crime or race and criminalization or race and hey you know what that dark man who is twenty years old Yep definitely going to commit a crime definitely And unfortunately that is what we think that is what is embedded in our society. So. That's just a little background stuff but I want to sort of focus on bringing to bear a different group of people all right so you guys at Melle I'm going to say lists look at women let's look at men OK Now there's a typically male female man and woman but it's really not that important here but what my big point is is that there are certain roles that people get are come into over the course of their lives such as being a parent or being in some type of relationship or it. And by relationship I'm talking about a type of romantic relationship and those roles actually influence how one experiences a family member being incarcerated you know if you were to guess. How would you feel if one of your family members was incarcerated. For your family member say your best buddy. Is incarcerated What's the first emotion that comes to mind your best friend scared. All right why are you scared what's going to happen right safety OK So now imagine then but have younger siblings. OK Anybody have older siblings I do to. All right. So imagine one of your siblings one closest to you in age being incarcerated and you get a phone call from jail and they say they've incarcerated and without Bill how do you feel angry. You know emotions embarrassed Yeah. Frustrated shocked ashamed. Guilty The ELSE I'M JUST name is on my emotions too so I can be a participant. Abuse All right. So when for me incarceration happens people experience a variety of emotions and what we know is that we expect them to actually be detrimental to the person however there are some studies that have actually found that for me the incarceration isn't quite as detrimental for some groups but again most of this has been done in relationship to how does it affect someone's child how does it affect. The mother left behind and we don't really get a nice intersection of roles and status and so in this particular study. Thinking about this from a sort of a historical point of view of the black family OK. If we think about black families in America and really what I mean are African-American families what you have is a family structure that still actually is a bit on the more extended in versus your sort of nuclear family structure but what you also have is a history where people have been removed consistently from the household through informal and formal social control methods or it so what I mean by formal informal social control formal social control are things like the police. Legislation there are formal ways in which we actually control the movements of people and then there are informal ways to say like a neighborhood watch or. Anger. Really. Just Getting Started All right so we're going to move on you must give a few things but you're just going to skip some things That's what have you. So academically talk a little bit more a little too much art but first I want to just talk about this idea of social control and how much it actually shows up in the lives of African-Americans so if you look at the furthest left going down you'll see these different Actually things are social control so please contact prior to adulthood All right can you imagine being arrested at the age of eleven or five. I can't but it happens reform school or juvenile detention that's sort of a nice way of saying that you're actually imprisoned but we're going to call a juvenile detention if you've ever been arrested incarcerated jail or prison and this is all among African-Americans of some representative sample of the U.S. population around the year two thousand and three familiar incarceration so immediate family member and then I look at any contact a form of social control and number of events experience or it so if we break this down by gender or the whole population. I want you to notice something just look at the ever arrested column and you'll see that among African-Americans. Over half of all African-American men have been arrested and about over a fifth of African-American women and it looks like almost a quarter of African-American men have been incarcerated and a little less than ten percent if we restrict it to just people who have some experience a form of social control you see something slightly different the numbers go up because I'm restricting the population Nevertheless if it was only due to something by proxy such as one might say familial incarceration we would expect the numbers not to be quite so high with ever arrested but people are experiencing a multitude of events in terms of interacting with formal so. Control but my point today is really more math skip this you know those are cool pictures I pick them out I did I write notes come in Georgia Tech got to be technological right savvy All right so very told you sort about this dataset and there are. A few different ways in which social scientists look at health sometimes well there's more than a few but one is just through social determinants of health and that's when we think about things such as age we know that people are older there's a higher likelihood of death education more educated you are typically the more. Things you have in your tool kit to help you navigate actually getting good health care except for a plum It always helps get a job after you graduate suffer port health and then there's another model called the stress process model which basically says. To be really quick. That these three things chronic stress mastery which means do you feel that you actually have power control over what you're doing and an ability to affect. I guess what happens to you and familial emotional support so hopefully your family is helpful but if everything is going fine and well and someone is incarcerated in your family then with the stress process model we would expect that there would be no extra effect due to form of incarceration right and so you're going to see some models and very quickly but. The stress process model which will be the second one is the one where we would expect for any sort of effect do to famille incarceration to go away all right so at the top we have women that's noted by that square with the Warman sort of kind of and then men you see it doesn't matter if you're black or white. OK although right now I'm talking about African-Americans and so here are these sort of intersections of roll right so you have women and there's a little word on her and there was every word I wonder though if. You read them first so for people who are not well we're not hearing what I read from more people who were turned into this like life stress right so general psychological distress. You know what they're like prices. So. For women who are here it doesn't go that far Boy you're the one one. Zero So let me just say that person ration really really stressed poor women who are single and also parents which is what basically has been shown by prior literature what it has not shown though is that men who are not here have their hearts really. Close yet they actually during this whole question that you play but. Yet men who are parents there's only a margin of. Why she was here is to get her so. Right I said this goes one very. Good Friend This would be for the women. And for us. What we're looking at here are in all that we want. To hear this army officer. Well of course so why is this happening I don't know still trying to figure it out. And about how many minutes I got. Now you try to tell me what started it we can do the rest from the camera. All right so. The. Last. Thing. I want to love people who are merely. Yeah. That. Was that very actually. The real reason being. That. There's free. Will. Like this. Where we're. Very. Rough. Rough rough and then it goes down for a while. Yet. We are very. Real Yes. But they are definitely distressed. So. Basically the whole point of this project was to sort of say you know what the story of incarceration it doesn't end with African-American men and you know what. Varies across the social roles that we typically take on. Things such as who are. You're a man all the romantic relationship all this and more. Well you see that side so. Finally. The biggest point is that the health. If you're walking with roll back the. Forces actually on the other side. And possible first think about. How awful things about our region socialist. Regime. Right. About. This whole that. Not just good Americans but people who somehow cross the path of formal social control and never get back out because once you go in it's. Sort of like the mafia except I don't know anything about the mafia I can tell you about the. What is it the Godfather story so we think about the Godfather. Which isn't real naturally but once you're in you can't you know. Thank you and I'm next because from Morehouse School of Medicine Dr Starling Harrison blanks. Right. Yeah they let me put this down here I do not have slides. Primarily because I spend a great deal of my time working with Forestier M.D. students and what I found is that it's important to know what you like. OK And what I found is sometimes when I show you many pictures that Indian students tend to get distracted very easily. Or in a medical students bioengineering OK Here my people public health people. Guess what if you're in this room you're a public health person because everything you do touches. But health is a wonderful Amberleigh So as was said My name is Starling Harrison blanks and I'm at Morehouse School of Medicine where I get to spend my days doing research on my primary population our research is traditionally focuses on help thinking behavior and African-American boys and men of color and what does that mean that means how do we put places people systems and resources in front of someone at the moment when they realize that they need help and in doing the work of boys and men of color that means unfortunately has been a great deal of my time doing research around of course aeration mass incarceration the Empacher the doctor just said before me on families and structures and communities because it's important to understand that's not over incarcerations of a population not only zaps the resources of those individuals who find themselves inside of a correctional facility but also zaps the resources and their ability to contribute to communities as a whole so as you think of graduation and what you're going to do next if you want to be a person who is an employer guess what incarceration directly intersects with employment if you want to be a person who's a health care provider incarceration directly them packed in by all of the social determinants of health so we see these threads throughout medicine throughout public health throughout industry and which incarceration negatively impacts these outcomes so I'm going to talk about money for a minute as I drove down here up I twenty I was looking at all the potholes in the roads and all of the different things that had to navigate to get here at least your campus has like parking even it was very fancy coming from my parking deck How does she think we spend on transportation inside the state of Georgia each year though I don't number. One hundred billion now that's how much we need to spend. We can guess. Two hundred million actually it's right around nine for the whole state nine billion dollars in the whole state Guess how much we spend on incarceration inside the state of Georgia hundred billion that's probably the next goal actually we spend one point seven billion dollars within the state of Georgia on incarceration and I'm not even talking about juvenile incarceration I'm also not talking about your county your cities none of that this is the state of Georgia so every time I run over a pot hole I'm thinking this pot hole could be field if they just incarcerated less people so you see how those things go when i guess which state agency inside of Georgia has the most Employees Health and Human Services. It's the Department of Corrections and guess what they have twice as many employees as any other state agency Now why is that that's because Georgia has the fourth largest incarceration population with in the United States of America which is very important when you think of the size of our state compared to the top three which is California New York and Texas Georgia is no where near them and size but we are here then when it comes into the number of people that we incarcerate and who are these people within our prison walls they are to predominantly going to be African-American they're going to pajama be male and they're going to predominantly have committed their first offense around the age of gets what. Fifteen. Remember what you were doing at fifteen probably dreaming of being a not a Tory I'm a Georgia Tech some day. I know me I was really really and to you know I'm not going to tell you going to date me but I was going to say that was flat bracelets involved I would there were jelly shoes there were all these things I was thinking about it that made the separate lives of. Some you know way too young for that well let's just say there wasn't a Facebook then but the thing is and since you didn't think of the things you were dealing with with your life think of all of how much you've drawn between fifteen and now and looking at your faces some of you were really really young so this wasn't too long ago Think of how much you've grown now imagine if the last seven to eight years of your life you had spent incarcerated inside of the state of Georgia what different of a person would you be now. And when you get out on your twenty first twenty second or twenty fourth birthday what would you do next you served your time right you're done no. Inside of the United States one of the few countries when we mass incarcerate people they serve their sentence and when they leave they are punished again. How are they punished when you go apply for a job what do they ask you Have you ever committed a felony. How are you punished when you're going to get an apartment or your family. Can Stay here are you a felon you can't work here but we still expect people who are released from incarceration to be able to pick themselves up by their bootstraps find a job find a place to live find a healthy nutritious foods to eat exercise sixty minutes a day and do everything like everyone else is doing without the social system structures and infrastructure in order to support them as they begin making this transition. That's something that we need to address as professionals we need to address to our systems our communities and our neighborhoods and let's talk about one of my pet peeves how many of you heard about the prison the school. Through the pipeline you've heard that phrase I hate that phrase because the pipeline is a pipe there's no way out I don't know I'm not a engineering major but I'm pretty sure they're solid as separately and. Which means you go in on one hand and that's it you're done I like to think of incarceration specifically when we think in terms of juveniles as an expressway because there are exits off the expressway that you can get all club and let's think about those exits for a moment the first exit off the prison to school the school to prison pipeline expressway if you want to think about it that way it's criminal justice reform this is something a lot of states are starting to think of lately because they've noticed that I'm spending ninety eight thousand dollars a year on average to incarcerate one juvenile offender how much is to wish in here. Well less ninety thousand. It is cheaper to send you to Georgia Tech than it is to incarcerate you for one year. What are our priorities so maybe a set of incarcerating you because once what they are incarcerated around the age of fifteen we know we've set them on a trajectory where there are three times more likely to be incarcerated as an adult if they have a parent that's also been incarcerated they are five times more likely to be incarcerated as an adult so when you put all of those factors together those social determinants together those multiple structure stressors together and you place them in one of those familial support systems which he was just what happens you have an overrepresentation are brown and black people inside of the criminal justice system. Criminal justice reform can absolutely address that not only through equal and fair sentencing but also looking at diversionary program so many of us have broken the law but never ended up in jail for it every time you have went down seventy five eighty five and you've been doing eighty instead of sixty guess what you have broken the law and if you got pulled over and you showed that student badge in the year now you did that right well I did it in undergrad. Had all kinds of things that way showed a material showed my student badge and they were like you're a young lady who's doing good things we're going to let you go. What would happen at the start of the set up and Starla. I was Stan. What would happen if I was a nineteen year old African-American male going twenty miles over the speed limit down seventy five. On a Saturday night maybe I get a ticket. Or maybe I get taken into jail now gotta play bail but I'm a pro college student I have no money so guess what now I have a weekend with in prison and we can in jail with real criminal. And then on this pathway one now Mon and cars incarcerated I mean with the system I'm on probation until I can pay my fine back I'm now one of those people who are under correctional supervision within the state so when we think of equitable treatment we have to think about changes that can be made to the policy lands the criminal justice reform and I know I don't have time to go through all the expressway exits but I want to tell you about what I think is very important employment. If people are going to exist they have to be able to. That's the basic need and we have a saying I've been working with some agencies here doing research around returning citizens and I call them returning citizens not X. cons are Fallon's because guess what three fourths who go in are going to come back out so we think about who is inside of prison systems we need to start thinking about the NOMIC later they're not. They're not just convicted felons these are returning citizens they are neighbors they are fathers they are mothers they're sisters or brothers they are people within our neighborhoods fabric who are going to be returning back to us so when they come back to us and I want to find employment that box on the application is the number one thing we could drop to help them get a fair chance it doesn't mean employers cannot provide a background check but it does mean that they can look at them for who they are their qualifications their expertise and find out is this person going to show up on time do the job I'm asking them to do for a fair wage and go home and in the day representing me well. Does the fact that they committed a felony and nine hundred seventy eight mean that they should not be able to work for you. Especially if they said it's their star their sentence they finish their time unfortunately that's what we think today and the third thing I want to talk about is at the top of the prison Expressway is absolutely education. We see so many linkages that we are working on right now to increase literacy in the fourth grade. You don't mind working in fourth grade as I was never meant to be an elementary school person I thought but I was speaking to a group of fathers in Mississippi who had spent at least three years within a correctional facility and we were talking them about what do you think you need when you get out and they said well I wish someone would I came in the prison when I was in there and talk to me about how hard it was going to be when I got out because they thought they would get out and go knock on every door and find a job or I said I wish someone would talk to me about my family and how my family has went on and grown without me because I'd left a very happy three year old and I came back to a very angry eight or nine year old. I wish they could have talked to me about that and one man stood up and he said I am fifty eight years old you know what I wish someone would do for me he said go back in time and talk to me when I was seventeen when I got arrested for the first time. So we ended up going over and doing a research project with juvenile offenders who were at Carver High School who's over in the west end of Atlanta area and we were talking to them thinking we're going to catch them they're seventeen we're right at the age when we could time to make sure they graduate on time half of the boys referred to us by the guidance counselor already had a probation officer that were in high school what should we do next so they said Well honestly. You should have gotten me when I was in middle school so before you know a long story short we ended up looking at literacy level and fourth grade students here inside of metropolitan Atlanta Atlanta public schools because what we were able to talk determine when boys who are unable to read a grade level and the fourth grade. Fourth grade because how young you are fourth grade when they're unable to read at grade level that's when we start seeing an increase and disciplinary infractions they stop paying attention stop coming to school on time and then that translate into middle school will then they have a new peer group in which they must become the cool kid with and learning and being in class I'm sure most of us all get called nerdy for want to pay attention in class at some point but you're already behind Let's be the class clown so the next thing you know you're getting into it you're getting an argument and do you know what happens inside of Atlanta public schools when you get in a fight on school property who knows what happens. Get suspended that would be wonderful now they call the police on you because they have police officers and father the public school in Atlanta so that's how you end up in my research having more black youth than I can even take into my study who are fourteen years old who has spent at least twenty days incarcerated inside the state of Georgia. So I ask you as you go forward to start thinking about what you want to do next and think about the intersections of race and mass incarceration and how it impacts what you do remember that this is a very long Expressway but there are exits off of it so think about what access you can create in your daily lives and your life as a student in your life as a young professional in your life as a researcher the can perhaps provide an opportunity for some of our returning to. Thank you thank you very much for the mother perspective and then our closing or our posing for the introductions you actually have a social activist so she there Vera from racial justice for their close close Soma Hey good afternoon everybody so my name is actually sold for Vera but that's OK and I am with the Racial Justice Action Center and I'm a community organizer and we have to grassroots projects one is called the solutions not punishment collaborative or snap Co and one is called Women on the rise and I'm really glad to be here to talk about this when I got invited I think part of my job is to really present a different perspective from Community Organizing from grassroots groups who are on the ground with folks who are being impacted by mass incarceration really criminalization and I'd love to just offer I think if we if you only talk about mass incarceration you're talking about one piece and you're talking about the prison system but a lot of what was just being discussed and that's really important of people's lives is. This is criminalisation right it's the whole the network from policing to probation to the culture of punishment to the in ground racism to prisons to jails and then all the private companies that serve those institutions so really I think it's important for us to look at criminalization when we're talking about its impact on health disparities and on the disparate like basically just racial justice in this country. So just to give you a little bit the Racial Justice Action Center an organizing and training center we're building leaders we're building power and the goal is to make social economic and political change in Atlanta and in Georgia so I hope no one saw me I was being rude and texting a little bit while folks were speaking and that is because our organization has been championing I don't know if anyone's heard of there's a push in the city of Atlanta to decriminalize marijuana to reclassify and you cannot be arrested for possession of under an ounce have folks heard about Excel and yet so that's actually happening right now and I left there to come here and as usual the city council members are engaged in many shenanigans so you have to stay very close on them to figure out what's going to happen. So that's you know part of what we do is we engage with the institutions that affect our lives we push to change policy and we're looking at in particular criminalization we also look at how to work across communities so we're very interested in how Latinos and black folks are working together how immigrant communities and domestic border communities are working together how trans unclear and system works are working together but because if we do not start to build a unified front around many of the issues that are impacting our communities we are going to continue to be sliding down the road that we've been on right now where we see a decrease racial justice increasing criminalization. And all of the kind of health disparities at that these two. I wanted to just say one piece that I think is important going from I like this expressway. Paradigm metaphor but I think it's really important for us to understand the history of the criminal justice system because you can get to this place where you're talking about and policy right now where you're looking at it like like it's a system like your education system or like our health care system and it serves a function and what's the sort of the function of the criminal justice I'm supposed to being safety right that's that is what is articulated and that is what is used over and over again to expand the reach of the criminal justice system I think it's really important say right now we live in a moment and those numbers are so important because we live in a moment where the criminal justice in is actually the largest domestic institution of our nation right it is larger than public health it is larger than our health industry or education institutions and in some ways I just want invite you to think about what that means for the culture of this country that we live in right within when people start talking about moving toward police state right when people try to say well it's no big deal when when our entire rhetoric and where the dollars go are to lock people in cages and to control people that has an impact on all of us right that has an impact on the culture of the world that we live and that I think we should be really. Vigilant about and then hopefully and part of my job here is to say engaged in trying to change. The so the history have people watch the movie thirteen or read The New Jim Crow and. OK we need to get the new Jim Crow. But but the popularisation of some of these movies and this book have been really incredibly helpful for us to just normalize the conversation that it's not an extreme thing to say that our criminal justice system literally literally is born was born in the moment that slavery was abolished by the thirteenth Amendment abolishes slavery except for in the cases where somebody has been and has had due process and has tried right this is the idea that excess slavery is abolished except in the criminal justice system in the very same breath right and why was this why the idea of slavery the institution of slavery the need to control socially economically and politically black bodies that was what the states. It's not going to let go of even after a slavery was abolished and the criminal justice system has been serving that purpose ever since it started off with convict leasing I don't know if people heard of that where literally a private company could you would be arrested because you were standing on a corner and then you would be brought brought into jail in a private company could bid on you to come work for them to do something like you know build the railroads after the Civil War in the South when they needed infrastructure desperately right there was convict leasing there were road crews right all of these evolutions that took place every fifty sixty years into what we call mass incarceration right now the mass incarceration we know right now is not actually doesn't go back to the beginning it's only that we've only locked this many people up with this many people in cages since the sixty's seventy's right incredibly clear backlash from actually the black freedom movement the civil rights movement. So when you understand from that's very inception it was designed for social control this myth of whether it keeps us safe or not has just been allowed to proliferate but actually everybody says over and over again there is nothing about it that creates safety right there is. There is a a woman who talks about the factors of violence and what contributes to it and it's isolation shame the inability to take care of your family or loved ones financially and exposure of violence the four absolutely critical cornerstones of what happens to a person in prison are isolation shame be in a billion take care of yourself or your loved ones financially and exposure to violence so we actually as a as a movement and people who are interested in anti violence as a health issue as a public health issue must be interested in in ending mass criminalization incarceration we are actually purpose. Weighting violence and harm through a system that knows very little other than punishment and shame and isolation right for those of us who have lived through harm for those of us who say well then what would happen right what should happen to people who commit who commit acts against other whose create harm and I think the question becomes when we've only been given this paradigm you know that thing is a if you're a hammer then everything was like a nail right it's like we have to actually be able to expand our mind outside of the criminal justice system to be able to envision a response to harm that actually centered the person who is harmed so how many times now do you have when somebody is actually harmed all of the focus is on who did it and what punishment they are going to get that person who is harmed is often left alone unsupported right it's not a system that's oriented actually towards protection or support of folks in our communities who are surviving harm. So I think that you know sort of blowing open this myth is is really very important and understanding the very specific history and that is because in all of our lives constantly there are things there are new laws and new policies that are going to get proposed and they're going to always ask for your vote and they're going to be elected officials who are campaigning on those slogans on the tough on crime I want to reduce violence we're going to do zero tolerance to gun violence right they all sound really good or nifty or interesting at least right and yet they all repeat the same thing any time you see a policy or person campaigning on harsher harsher penalties longer sentences more money for jails more money for police that's what I want to urge that's what happens and that's what we as individuals as a grassroots oppose a community of students as professors need to stop need to start saying no we're not going to vote for that we're not going to support that anymore in fact we're going to we're going to. We organize against it so in our organizing right now we had about a room full close to this number of people in our city hall packed to say to the Atlanta Police Department into the city council who have been opposed to this for a long time that we no longer want to see people arrested for possession of marijuana under in particular when we know we live in a city that's fifty three percent black and everyone knows that all races use marijuana at the same rate and so an equitable rate of a arrest would be fifty three percent of the arrests for marijuana would be of black folks in the city of Atlanta ninety three percent of the arrests for the possession of marijuana are black that's an extreme disparity for which there is no explanation other than racially biased policing in Atlanta right where people want to at least look and say where we have black elected officials the mayor our police department right but that's how entrenched and I appreciated that discussion from earlier that's how entrenched the biases that's how entrenched the internalized and externalized racism is right we have created a culture where people and in particular police officers whose job is actually to keep us safe are really out kind of looking for who's the criminal. So I think I'll end it there just because I know we'll get to have lots more discussion but I just want to say I hope that there are questions or curiosities it's my job any time I'm in a room because we're a membership based organizations that were always asking people to join and be a part of the movement to transform the criminal justice system in the land and mostly what we specifically say to divest the resources out of our criminal justice some sort of close our city jail to reduce our police force right and to put that money our jail costs thirty two million dollars a year just to city jail so all those billions of dollars were time on the state level let's just go to Atlanta Atlanta and thirty two million dollars a year on a city jail that. I don't know folks you know but we have a county jail that holds misdemeanor and felonies folks who are charged with misdemeanors and felonies our city jail holds people on traffic offenses and city ordinance violations think spitting on the sidewalk think jaywalking four hundred people sit in there every day right and thirty two million dollars a year goes to locking those people up Imagine if we put that thirty two million dollars towards our education system towards housing for people in this city right the things we could do and I really believe even though the big numbers are overwhelming to me here in Atlanta we can do that we can do that we can close our city jail and grab that thirty two million and have a different situation in many of our communities so I just want to and recruit and invite all of the folks here to get involved on that level. To do that work thank you. Thank you OK So think about questions while we reorganize up here all right so OK so a lot of just moderated discussion and because of that I get to take moderator's license with opening with a question for Dr Patterson because she talked about the new the new iteration of her work on the familial role of incarceration but she also again this is a group that we talk about health that and a race as a medicine but I was first really intrigued with the word because she actually has these She actually the details quite quantitative which is a quantitative sociologist that I discovered appreciate but if you could really talk about some of the things that you discussed really about the effects of incarceration on reducing life expectancy but I think that was some of the shocking work that I first. Saw of yours that you can explain that to the to the communities they were not aware sure so at some time ago I started well actually so I dish least started looking at incarceration because I wanted to bring some context to the idea of what it means to actually be incarcerated part of that as the. Lager from it looking at Age Pacific death rates. And so I looked at the ages of death rates of people who are actually harsher it specifically in state correctional facilities and I notice that it conform to the J. shaped curve for the gum parts curve that we're used to seeing we look at mortality in populations. And so it's a close sort of crazy I don't know about this and I took a step back. But it was it was just it was a very fascinating finding and I moved on to want you to look at not just the incarcerated population but population to see how my incarceration actually influence life expectancy after your release from prison. And so I learned that for every year one spends in prison they lose two years of life expectancy. Now this is alarming and it was alarming to me alarming so much that I sort of let that thing go for a bit and then I went back to and I said OK let me take all the data and stuff whatever. But it was right. And I had the privilege of actually looking at well you know what it is. I was in a courtroom I wasn't on trial but I was in the courtroom for it and it turns out that in the state of Michigan at least any juvenile who has been sentenced to life without parole they don't make it past forty years in prison they die so that means that they are not making it to the age of deathly not sixty. Probably somewhere less than sixty three they don't make it because there's something very toxic about being in they have to take their space but not just being in that space but even afterwards such that the United States pellet court decided that Senate saying somebody. To life without parole is actually harsh an unusual punishment specially for juveniles and they ruled against it in the set only in the recent cases but just sticking in regular cases when people have been sentenced to such long terms actually my work has been used to show that this is cruel and unusual punishment because really they're going to die when they get out. OK so that's a sobering thought I look for questions from the audience she's going to one of the. Stories. You. Might. Have would like to tackle that some of the research that rigidly disagreed the question for a very good question the centrally of around it and the intersection between mental health in a harsher ration and how that leads to be fitted as a more additional arrests and also the treatment of individuals and mental health disparities mental health issues while a lot of correction this is one of the populations that we're really focusing on now because we've seen this correlation between the frequent flyers at their level thirty Gelett of Forth in county jail which are people who come in and out of here who are a lot of times there are individuals who have and I'm good diagnose that's a health condition or they have that's a health condition but don't have stable access to medications so we normally do see this trajectory where fortunately someone on commits an offense they go into that the county jail facility they began being assessed and they say OK this person in the bottle learns gives a friend. They're not on medication. So they're put them on medication long enough to get them through trial and then they get released on bail and they kids seven days of medication upon Really and what do they do in that seven days afterwards. That you have to go stand in line for them to now or is it crazy to get a thirty day supply or are they in the splitting pills life until they become mentally deteriorated state until they end up with that of being so that's the first thing we look at is that there is definitely a need to create more diversionary program particularly for those who commit offenses and who have a diagnosed mental health condition and there are some accountability quote that are looking at that now with in Georgia we actually have one in Fulton County a behavior health court where just deals where people who committed a felony offense and have a diagnosed mental health issue that's one side of the core and the other side of the coin is what happens within the corrections they have begin shutting down a lot of the mental health hospitals this is one of those big budget cuts that's where when it was they when the elected officials are talking about being tough on crime and putting more dollars in five corrections they meant within prison though to do that one way to save a lot of dollars where they stay shuttered the statements of the prison it was rich with the Jackson Georgia so what that means is that individuals who are through the early start time and who have uncontrolled mental health issues then we're not talking about people for mental health concerns with medications we're fine we're talking about actual people with Luther's they're now going to be housed alongside she had pot or within a whole pot. So what happens when you are person who is going in for your dialysis treatment by the way second largest dialysis provider within the state of Georgia the Georgia Department of Corrections Yes they're bigger than the you know what you see with any of the veto Dallas's around the corner is that she stayed in Georgia so you're going there for dialysis treatment you're in fact to help on and you're locked in. Now individuals who have psychosis. That really does create an unsustainable and terrible situation which we do believe is cruel and unusual and unfortunately when people are released the trauma that they suffered a lot of times only it's asked for a sense of race there's a health condition and there's not enough community providers to see the only other side so if you want to make a really big difference look into technology and think about it from the outset back to really be a community provider for these heart to see her profile ation especially those who have a sexual base the fifth I can't find a place for them to go to get treatment when they get out of state correction of one of the things that said Yeah I was trying to respond to the far. Right like we know that incarceration creates mental illness like create that P.T.S.D. that's being talked about that people come out when the conditions being such that that make it very hard to there's the structural barriers when you get out and then there's the barrier is ray of your own mental health struggles and trying to reacclimated and overcome all of the structural pieces and I just think it's really important for that's for me why I really believe in the organizing of formerly incarcerated people and I have seen some amazing powerful organizing in the state of Louisiana people who serve ten fifteen twenty twenty seven years in Angola and as a penitentiary coming together to work at night with each other because they understand that they've been there right and actually the kind of low level of feeling and love that comes to other people just when you survive that Sony has just like led a different kind of organizing that a lot of what we see and so I just want to offer a lot of media that's one of the things to support because even even that then when you're coming out yes it's great if you could have access to the services really you also need a support system of people who've been through what you've been really. You are going to have like all kind of judgment and questions for you as you can join with. Just a one who is out of here you know and you know the next time you know usually there's a. So just a sort of bounce off of what you're saying. So if you think about think about the. V.A. OK you know over the past decade couple decades lots of different things have come out about scandals about veterans not being treated correctly respectfully and not getting the proper treatment we know that the V.A. The should be better for it and one of the things that we have learned a lot from veterans is about P.T.S.D.. And so it was I was talking to somebody I don't know which is that but I don't know and and we were having just special P.T.S.D. and I was talking about formerly incarcerated people he was talking about veterans and he said you know is the stupidest thing I don't know why people have this expectation that when you are when you get out of incarceration or when you're release that you're going to be OK We've known that that's not the case for veterans for all this time so why are we expecting this same thing some some perfect person to come out. And just be able to reintegrate into a society that has already basically lost all of their opportunities that's a vision I mean it's a traumatic experience it is a traumatic experience and for the most part it depends on I guess you your family and your social support system etc But people don't actually like to talk about it all right so what happens when you go home we were like hey you good and like yes and that's it. So. So actually having that sort of space to open up and talk about the experience I mean I have friends I have family members who've been incarcerated I have no idea what went on but I know I'm not supposed to ask the question I'm supposed to wait. When we have a real question of that first because. Sure. If you look if you have figured out a trick I get there's a question that are in the room. So the question is as with minimums first book first protocols about minimum sentencing laws and what should be done with those of how the length of time with which someone remains incarcerated affect their rehabilitation or really interested when they get back out. So. I think it up I mean I think the simple answer on the mandatory minimums is just we should get rid of them. They are definitely a product I feel like to have fun trying and they need to you know just for it than a thing and so you know this sort of real simple thing on our state level in our federal level is just minatory not have that as a huge failure and we should feel that I think that I've not done the studies and maybe folks who are more academically. Parted like would you to say so if you like if you spend a year what are your outcomes two years when you're out and seven years when you're out on my instinct is probably what yours is which is that if you're outcomes get worth. And you know over your time maybe that levels off in a certain amount at a certain time but I think that you know I think we should really think about looking at anything was ever just opened up to code your state code and seen the extent of the criminal code and in Georgia and in many other places it's the largest section of the code it's got tons and tons I think that we should actually be thinking both at the sentencing and also just taking things off the books like like who like this idea that there is a crime and so we need to figure out a question for the poor child who decided that was a crime right there been crimes from the beginning of time then a leg you know leg we would have a question there are public health issues that isn't a crime that is and that is an issue of public health that the public of the permit should be addressing and their behaviors and people and that bother other people so I think that that's where we see the direction we should be going into is really about actually how we just stripped our criminal code many of the things a lot of love. I would have to that just by saying that I'm strongly against minimum sentencing I believe people spend a lot of time going to school to become lawyers even more time the employers to become judges let's let them show us their own judgment of that the second thing I would state and that we know is that it's in there she said it is really about tough on crime and human mind I believe we should be tough on crime that is going to be tough on crime but there's a difference between being tough on crime and being tough on criminals and both of them are not those two things are the same and I think they're talked about interchangeably but you can be tough on someone who let's say they picked your pocket and they went to Coles and Barber just offered your credit card you're mad at them do you think that person should spend three years in jail and should be put in solitary confinement for ninety days at a time because guess what sanitary confinement decided by the warden in the the jail staff is not something mandated by. Judges. I've had that happen to juveniles that I've worked with where they've literally got their credit families some use that one of the credit card went to Target and then literally spent over half of their nine months that they were inside of a natural R Y D C about a solitary confinement so when you think about the health outcomes of that if we could have heard what you said we don't have to watch and think about what happens later often and fashion to if it's just later because he couldn't deal with his life. For the local here my See over there will start I have two thoughts that come up in this. One of my just say yes or no they're related to the relationship so in your research or are you making more having type of distinction between violence and not. And if so what are those. And then my second question is around Has anyone looked at. Issues of relationship building when someone reenters overturns it is. Particularly now. Males when they come out and perhaps try to gain jiggly when it comes to even getting in relationships with them. And you know looked at even then and how that might. Be development of family after. You spoke of the familial books would you like to tackle the first. Or the violent versus not alone for the family first which are. So in one area of my research I would get. I guess you know I'm going to spin off with the sentencing so I would agree with the middle men for millions being. So waste time and money and. The thing that is always very striking about our sentencing policies and the changes that we see going on so you know it's Bri if we're able to actually make marijuana. A ticket a fine versus something that goes on your record as no need whatever because what Atlanta and what George and general which state correctional people have cited is that you know what yes we need to be better with nonviolent crimes but will find crimes we're going to the punitive less pay and so we still want to be tough on crime but we want to be reasonably tough on crime and so. The outcome has been that lots of states have taken steps to actually decriminalize a lot of things but they've also increased the link with us today for violent offenses and with the hope that that will actually lower the cost but that doesn't lower the cost that actually raises the cost and we see like the short term minimum decrease in the actual size cost of doing all this incarcerating thing and then it goes right back up. One of the things that can happen with the decriminalization though is that we sort of take away the mark of a criminal record and what that means because we actually have legislation on the books that says hey you know what you cannot be a barber if you have a felony on your record you cannot participate in this tree if you have a failure record whether that's an electrician a plumber so all of these sorts of you know skilled jobs that pay good money that legally you cannot do with a felony point your record that's in the criminal code. Including a constant ologists just another of how this kind of college just because of the licensing That's because the license. So why is that in there. Well. No one reads it right doesn't matter if you're not affected. Going to the familial relationships and what happens when people come out so I think that people are very excited about the idea of like going home one of the things that inmates talk about. Are least inmates that I've talked to talk about a lot is what they're going to do when they get out great excitement and and then they get out and they feel very isolated and. If they don't have people who are actually like saying hey come on do this they will it's it's just really hard they don't have the actual family support and the family doesn't have economic resources to sort of a mill you read the actual legal ways in which we block opportunities of people with a record that is extremely hard so getting a job that is so important because in your identity is not just in the fact that you are this person who has been discarded and call this convict or this villain or the ever dirty word you want to use for that day then all of a sudden you know what you are you have a job you have something else to talk about you have another conversation to have versus a conversation you're not having because of all the shame and other things the other thing is that if your family is actually depending on any type of government resources then in some states you actually cannot live with your family you're barred from their bar for housing you so where exactly do you live because when you are released from restoration it's not like they give you money they drop you off you're there so you're back in the world pay your release but you have nothing so that what I had to connect is that one thing to that what did that. Thank reason they do give you twenty five dollars in the check in your name but most of the time you don't have an ID so you can't even catch the check so this is actually you do leave with nothing in all of them and speak a little bit about made availability which I go all in on that but here's something that understands when people come home they do they have been planning for like four or five not years when they get home in the first they come home everybody's like and J.J. is back in a coma party and they take him to the gold room and everything happened. And then the next day grandma or mom up job ever they're staying with because they have their wife or girlfriend and them better to stay healthy and they can't stay there if they have a drug related felony which I'm not I wanted him to hear everyone's I said OK I'm so glad you're home you're good and then of course you have to say OK because you can't really talk about your trauma the very next day going to be you got a job yet you got a job. Because who's asking family or the families asking friends or asking in these this is your supports that. They're asking you for something made when you are ready feel bad and then they can go back to work Mom and get to go back to work grandma get to go back to do what she was doing before you were there the kids are going back to school think about the focus on elation that you feel that that's one of them out with circles are really important to be able to reconnect and employment is so important but when they look at trying to really reconnect with their family they don't know how and this is where made availability come then when you're inside of a correctional facility you only get to make around thirty to thirty five decisions a day when you come out you have four hundred this think about it how many of you today decided what shirt you're going to wear you don't have that decision what shoes you're going to wear and you only have two pairs they're white or gray that's it so to come out and decide am I going to sit in this chair or that chair am I going to be able to wear the blue shirt the pink shirt or no. Had those little minute decisions and how that impacts your life so when you think about reconnecting with family and reconnecting and trying to start relationships be interrupted too that you have for nine years of not being able to make decisions that really does impact made availability here and impacts relationships in a whole lot of other help outcomes that we see that negatively impacts people sometimes they feel like if I don't feel connected to socially isolated I don't have a job it's easier for me to go back and make that money has any say in the West End The streets are always hiring. And that's with a no I want a pretty big a back up there we're going to go soon as I can especially this coming out and this made availability and relations for establishing them with wives and girlfriends that they love me with it so well you know Georgia not have the right to but they discussed this Georgia of course of the study in the presence of a J.P. transmission acquisition in prisons that they did cut short when they started to see the actual numbers and I would I would love to hear if you walk up actually offer your insider or information for the audience about eight of his resignation and about ninety eight on the sunny weather then reconnecting with partners and mates because again I love your point about seventy five percent are coming out and people have to really come to grips with that but whatever thoughts you like to add to that I'd love to hear. As a black woman in Atlanta it started out to that other bed I'm in now thank goodness it was a little better than that what if he can tip you don't know this is really interesting a little bit of policy changes that we need to get your groove on they test you for a job becoming and they do not test you coming. By that would say something about transmission while inside and we know there's things that we're going to tend to not happen inside but we do see that and then they come out and if your mate it's been away from seventy years you can say I'm going to meet you who's been in a single. The market I'm going to need you to take if T. test before we recommit What are you what are you saying about that and how are you going to do that so this takes this is beyond condom negotiation this goes to a whole different level and unfortunately there is a correlation it was the inside of Fulton County with the transmission rates among African-American women and the zip codes in which we have the highest number of authorities that the. So that's one of those programs that probably needed some of these are pretty good the distributors Yes you can have hundreds and hundreds and spend there and then have condoms and present to the to me to use as a weapon and or me to transmit illegal items so and if I can just build on that I love it because I mean that's really am especially when we talk about heterosexual couples and but let's be real and terms of the disproportionate impact of criminalization and incarceration on queer and transform as well and and you know and already astronomical grades of each I'd be in for a transfer because a good black transit trans people of color and the lack of health care the lack of access to health care because those are some extreme disparities that exist and then I just think there's something about the treatment of folks inside as well so you know or just how it impacts each other the status we had a call a couple of months ago and one of our members with HIV positive she's a trans woman and we went and bailed her out of the city jail and she's been there for you know four days right on some charge and they tell you you need three hundred dollars you can do fifteen days it's called Pay or stay so you got the money to get out you get out right you don't have the money that they're so it's a guy's a few days to get the money again and we get the money but by then it's your nature and you meant I don't know how many folks here know about your paycheck Yes but you have to take them every day what happens when you stop taking them is you actually can you build up a resistance to them and you have to get on a whole different regimen and you know and that means right another one of your sixty eight hour days at Grady waiting for that so I just want to highlight leg just to be. No I think there's many. There's many pieces and I think what's hard in the each ID conversation that the sex in prison conversation is it can start to just be toward. Demonizing or or there can be homophobia and transcribe it inside of a conversation and I'll try to say is right next it's normal it happens it happens everywhere including in prison and right at the idea you can have condoms and side is because we're pretending that that doesn't happen right and just like you can be arrested for having a condom if you're a person if they think of doing sex work out on Peachtree Road because you're condom can be used as evidence that you're prostituting right select but then the that that is sort of opposite the reverse thought. Around what would actually be there people wanted to keep people safe keep people healthy the different kind of all of that would be just a second take Kentucky as their only separate state that does allow condoms inside of jail but that's because of a research study they did the University of Kentucky a lot of the medical practitioners where they are and they begin to it's not Palestinian realized they had a rocket raid but they just have the transmission was that it was a federal rule or is it state by state by state and in the federal prisons are they are like for me or how does that I don't think she'll be yeah no OK you know the jurors have of know with the disease and here centers of state civil. Relationships in prison OK so what or or jail in jail or prison so if you're incarcerated then. And you're there for uncertain number of time which is think about this like you did it from an emotional standpoint right I keep Yes you love motions but barely so first of all when you're actually a cursor is you go through this whole process in the stripping this dehumanizing process and then you're told where to be were to go and you don't know. When your ex your case is going to be called if you do know when you have you actually have some sentence or whatever you know you're going to be there for some time or jail that's one year or less. Prison that's typically Bill Nighy and more than one year and so what do you do what do you feel where you who are your friends OK so maybe you're used to being able to hang out with people maybe you're not maybe you're used to at least seeing friends and maybe you actually hug your friends maybe you don't have your friends I don't really know but what I do know is that for people who are incarcerated there is an extra layer of isolation and an extra layer of just trying to survive the at the not knowing what happens next. And with that comes relationships. And they're not all sexual but maybe you have a relationship so I'm going I'm using a story from. A former inmate OK and there was this there are there are these behaviors that people who have night the sort of the sort of just like a couple of things I don't know if there was sexual intercourse going on or not but this was one of the things that they did so that they could feel some connection to a human being. And so right now we're having a conversation we can connect with one another this is interpersonal but if you're in a space where you know absolutely nobody and you don't know when you're going to get out or you know that you have to somehow pass the time in some way but you still you're in for that thing that most people do yearn for which is a touch feeling some sort of connection. It has from. Their site. So on we're. Numbers zero one zero. Zero three zero. Zero we're going to work for you you'll return how are you going to do on. Some other job with no one to talk. To you don't you know that there are quite. Capable folks read my very words on you with overs to read something. You don't really know you ever did you. Were the. Number we're somebody here. OK so. So what I'm hearing there or whatever Middle East able to take away and that's not you that's like the me is said here curious about OK well when people actually do start to talk then what happens next or what are some of the outcomes for people who we do talk to or set resolute hundred one of them to go over there. So in a different study they did that look still specifically at that of the African-American men. One of the one of the strange findings for us was that African-American men who were formerly incarcerated and were currently free when they had a family member that was a curse or rated their psychological distress actually went down. And so typically we would expect psychological stress that go up if you have a family member who's incarcerated. Particularly though you're formerly incarcerated you know it goes on but it went down and so one of the hypotheses about why you doubt it is that. Now there is somebody in your family who you could talk to if you wanted to there's somebody who could understand you if that's what you want to do typically we know that men don't visit men in prison instead women are the ones who are visiting men in prison and they're typically taking a lot of for bull abuse because people do that to people who they know will come back and the reason the women continue to come back your mom keeps coming back even though you don't talk why aren't you talking because you don't want to bring her any more pain and yet both of you are hurting your stream but going back to these two this whole like strange finding about men. And when they get out and there's another family member that is incarcerated Yes the actual told those down but for women that doesn't have them it goes up. And so why does it go up for women why not for mere. I would attribute it at least with African-Americans to the matriarchal structure of the population and women always sort of not always but seen as at least the caretaker of the household how could I let this happen on my watch will maybe it was all about you but certainly this is how you've been trained to think about your role in the family and so whenever something happens sit in my brother's For example they meet some nice young lady or whatever. My brother has is this really funny way of saying it says you don't have to worry about my mother you have to worry about my sister you have to get through my sister if you want to get actually approved into the family. And I take it very seriously the messages are. Not going to stick with the mother load up with. Serious to do with that for President of the book cover of that OK good. Luck trying to write things like. That right it is looking at some of the question yes I'm wondering if there is a. Problem so anxiety is also actually looked at on this particular skill. In terms of trauma so. In this particular study I am not looking at past trauma in other studies I am looking at problem and specifically trauma that occurs. So that it's quite normal unfortunately for young people to see young people who are in marginalized communities to see friends be killed or to lose their parents early for them to die or a premature will what I'll call premature death. For lots of trauma to occur but it's also very much almost normalized there's the expectation this this is fatalistic view but it's not exactly feel is that if you actually see it happening both we would call it being fatalism and so if your expectation is that you're not going to live beyond the age of sixteen How does that modify your behavior what does that mean it probably means that you know what if you're going to have a kid you probably need to have kids soon. So. I mean it so yes. In short yes my my son my other work looks at actual past trauma and that's the work that I deal with that actually uses longitudinal data. And also I think of trauma in terms of OK will have you had some of those in a different interactions with the parole justice system those are traumatic events. And yet they're now you know all the events because I couldn't I couldn't ask people OK So have you had any sort of negative if you know action with the police or have your friends have you seen this happen Have you seen one of your parents arrested and these are things that become so normalised and yet they take such a toll on a person's body because it means that they are constantly in fight or flight response and it is literally weathering as one person with a drop of us whether in a way the body to the degree that most African-Americans do not see any kind of social security because they died before that past. QUESTION Yes I'm just depressed now where you got the Hankins we've got you've got the trucks and police. And loves that you think you have to do there's there's some really wonderful federal models like that to recognise those parkas models they could be put into correctional setting particularly that intermediate to long term we're talking County and I'm thirty jell facilities and what it costs or actually begin to chant Google sort of works I'm sorry works P.R. and see it's a really wonderful model where looks at her benefits because what we find is that sometimes when a person is in fact correction particularly those who may have a behavioral health concern or a diagnosis is that they may have heard bit of this if they qualify for and this is a wonderful time to start registering them for the benefit of us get them registered and they have be a bit of at the out there with get them registered or at least do their application for Medicaid system times what are you going to correction their Medicaid up. OK Should a Medicare application is terminated let's get them connected if they have died or disability Let's go ahead and start doing those benefits while they're in five so that the day of hundred lease they either have if they have their package their applications completed or all they have to do is go one place because it's very difficult to tell a person who's been incarcerated particularly those never behavioral health concerns you have seven as a premeditation I need you to go to the F The diving to go to V.A. any to go to you know you made it happen I did all these different things like if we could get that done ahead of time still upon release I don't really have that that need the application but they also have their applications for benefits they have and I'm like a State ID that don't work you can't even with a decent hotel room without an I.D.. Having those benefits available and also doing more inside out programming where practitioners who do transitional living and how they were able to meet clients on the inside so they can go ahead and make a plan for their first thirty days from the outside that first thirty days it's critical whether it's from jail or county or from President making a plan for what you're going to do every day for that first thirty day helps keep people out of trouble because there are seven days the dangers are because everyone's like yeah it's great amount of people legit hang around for a day or two but come dates four five six and seven you need a plan of where to go so I think that would be really really really critical is just making sure those current benefits that medication assistance is in place before they even walk out of the door because keep in mind many people they'll fight will back through and they may not have had their meds if they left prison or jail the last time. Yes. Why. Why. Like a very different place today. So I let you all decide why drape a rope. Read up on you very much it is you want and I really got a. Barrel inverses crack was never a while now are drugs shipped in policy express what how can you what is your best advice for how they can be proactive at this stage they are to make a difference and the third is if you started to get away these days mommy. Will you can do to replace it that's my privilege because. I will just say the first question I think is really is you know around the drug war and you know the war on drugs and I think it's a perfect example of whatever speaking of earlier kind of like a rhetoric that's built around how are going to you know eliminate drug addiction or whatever and what you've done the next day you've increased and we've seen an uptick in addiction and public safety was not a proved but thousands upon thousands upon thousands of black and brown people in particular were looked into jails and prisons and so that's now with the War on Drugs is a valid. And and yes you see that when it's opioids in white communities the funding all of a sudden Congress is like my god I'm going to put money towards exploring addiction and towards public health responses you know and that disparity that is so it's so stark it's just so bleak. But you know what we can take from it or vary from it at least is that the way it's being talked about with that opioid crisis it is and the bunch better friend for all of us and for all our communities in what we're fighting for from like a public health perspective for our medical care as I see it is how do we treat addiction you know I mean in some ways in this country we're like so far behind on that very nice. And I think many many of us struggle with our own addictions are people that we know and love who have addictions and we've been like totally flooded with this idea of like abstinence only at twelve step and you just have to have the willpower to say here is really no understanding of it not the brain science of addiction no understanding of harm reduction and so. So I feel like. Yes So I just I moseyed like it's really important to be kind of like visually to be looking at some of the things that are being put in the place because a little bit of the fact that way. But to you know to it's like another just place of really your hypocrisy around what what we're actually trying to do and to say the criminal justice system is a completely. Ineffective and and you hear me response to it. The second there or the very question. Very question was how it really ways to break the state many of you still get a lot of I think that there is you know I actually really dealt with this very practically and dealing with in the city of Atlanta and all of our memories because. There's all this cost easily you say we're going to stop on the state level they're looking at three criminalizing traffic offenses so George is one of the few states where you you're driving without a tail light and that will land you in jail most times. Yann that is and so that's who's in our city jail a lot of people drive a good ten hours actually like driving with your tires out all the way inflated in the ratio. So those kind of types of the state wants to do that and the biggest opposition comes from the municipal and the county government who are like well you want to zip zero that's not buying training and so what we've been trying to do is is really tough couple things one is like you don't take money from the poor to give to the rich but that's not how we should run things right and that's what happened to those who get picked up for those violations or whose car gets chosen to be pulled over right and all of their race and class disparity there mean that you're always its most vulnerable folks it's always folks who have the least money and that's what you're milking your fines and your feet are out of and then they can't pay is going to get another fine right I don't know if you all know the preparation thirteen you go in there are you tracking to get and they say we got three hundred dollars today off the menu if but if you don't agree and I say we'll put you on program. And you can pay up to three hundred dollars over the twelve month period but you also pay a forty dollars a month probation and then you get from a company in your life I don't need a drug test you and you're like I'm in here because I had a tail light you know and they're like We got a drug test use That's another twenty dollars drug test and you got to do what every month right so you literally go racking up three thousand dollars worth of fines and fees at the end of your at the end of your year right because you didn't have to be right so that is taking from the poor to give to the rich right and what that case for most often is like the judges that the clerks salary the infrastructure right like you did it's that institution that has less self interest right so you do come up against a restrung opposition I think the flip side of that in a public policy way is to look if you have a massive amount of dollars that go particularly into. The bricks and mortar of this. Because that money comes out of the general book fun and just goes to that and it's it's I think maybe an argument why you can't just change the policies but leave the prisons and jails you've got to get rid of the prisons and jails because you know they always anything if there is a bad thing if they will build it. And so you've got to close down that is the jails we better refurbish them going to turn them into other things so that they are not there and they're not something that's dollars and I think that's where the coffee and coffee in this is actually reduced hurts region and closed down. Then you know that along the expressway which is a question of or two I would say that structural functional little is really critical and not to be under sold but they have made that change with the engine for now corrections where they started moving away from warehousing juvenile offenders and put in the more into communities that Inskeep in the reconnected with families and they show that that decreases their likelihood of going to incarceration as an adult so that's one of those mitigating factors but keep in mind being right is not enough we a lot of parents have to talk that dollars and cents argument that for example the guy. Near Georgia came out like three years ago say I want to do heads to criminal justice reform for juveniles and all of the advocates I was elected to the main thing and then went to a meeting with him and said we're paying ninety eight thousand dollars a year that we cared about saving was ninety eight thousand dollars a year you know what I will take it and I will talk about the ninety eight thousand dollars a year you get a day and stead of twelve thousand in community corrections I think that's really wonderful and it's current when you can do I talked a little bit earlier and I talk about the criminal justice policy and the education and employment there's three more Packers I think of the never went that you can do is they get it from a community and family structure you have to be open and willing to connect to people when they return home from incarceration and she said that family reconnection and having that increase that might be expected the we have to be able to do that and realize or people are coming from the banking thing and looking at media there are the cavalry's iterations of old tropes and stereotypes of who's committing crime then who's the drug users then I think of the heroin epidemic and so amazing really quick story is they Indiana there was no needle exchange because needle exchange was for and I'm quoting it there Fishel they are dirty brown drug users. All that said there was a Chevy epidemic that broke out in a rural area of India all the sudden the governor of Indiana the time a guy named Mike Pence may have heard of a good God Guess what little exchange we need this is only going to be in certain counties and only in rule areas so you don't have needle exchange and Gary where you have those dirty brown drug users but you do have it with the fine upstanding young people who live in the rule areas who are just been hit by the opioid epidemic or face of this is really a policy issue but still the way that we talk about Carol when addicted mothers pregnant women but we talked. About crack babies that's a media term So think about pushing back on that make sure you use the Right now the plagiarist specially use your shelves of media and networks think about the kind of images you're retreating and sharing in where they're coming from that along with communities and family and then of course helping housing housing housing if you have a place if you air B. and B. if you are going into a place asked him a question about it just ask the question maybe we're not going to take every family live but I really that telling the real story guy but the one leg who had committed a felony and nine hundred seventy eight if he lost his leg due to uncontrolled diabetes that wouldn't go all the way up if we could not find housing for him because he was a convicted felon so we finally got Richard transitional living facility but he committed a felony and nine hundred seventy eight most of the people this room were not your parents may not even been bought of the nine hundred seventy eight so this is some of the something last year we were dealing with so just thinking about that when it comes to housing policy absolutely out of date. So I'll keep my response sort of short but that's what I'm going to be sure so respect to the first question thinking about this sort of different responses to. Heroin versus crack versus whatever else you want to call it. One of the things that I asked my sister do is to think about it different more on drugs so. I did know this when I actually started working at a particular university not necessarily want that right now but. Apparently there are some majors where the expectation is that you will abuse eighty eight drugs now this is not to say that P.T.S.D. drugs are not helpful for people who are actually diagnosed with it but it is a felony for somebody. To actually give eighty or eighty H.T. trucks to somebody or to take somebody else's which is a prescription all right and so I asked them to say OK so you know what this is a very harmful thing it can cause death among populations particularly when we're looking at elite college campuses with fraternities and sororities So if we were going to actually wage a war on drugs where do we start who is starting college campuses and we would actually look for turn of people who are members of her tourney's and members of swords so who would be in this room still versus who would not and what would our complete college university layout look out look at look like right now. Just think about those things as you consider the terms all those criminals and those and then in other ring of people because really is somebody a criminal if they don't get caught. I don't know you have to tell me but what about that person who didn't commit a crime but was convicted of one or had to plea guilty to one so they can get to work the next day so they would be fired so they could support their kid. Are they a criminal so. I'm just going to what you say and watch what what a laugh if you say these words are are very extremely powerful and extremely hurtful and painful and you never know the experience of the person sitting next to you the color of their skin is not going to tell you what they look like other words not going to tell you only they can tell you with their experiences and if you deserve to actually hear about or not. So let's because there was a question over here that I was looking for but I'm going to do you have been a committed. Yes. Chris I'm going to get the rights that cannot be significant to get the letter I honestly think it's like today because I hope each one of you have an opportunity to have heard at least one thing that you had not thought of before or maybe not in that way any Each one tells one that really does help to spread the word because I'm looking out at a group of people who are probably going to have the opportunity to be employers or elected officials in the future and I would hope that you take what you heard and apply that to your life and what you do on the day whether it is when you're walking down the North Avenue see that guy talking to thoughts I think about hey wait a second they did close fighting for the middle help but also now he's been held in a jail to believe that he doesn't have that that they care think of it like that and what you can do because that's really important and so we start seeing that this impacts all of us it's not just a black issue or brown issue this is something that really impacts all of us it's our internal lives and that and how we you know react and go about and think of when you're doing research a way that you can engage and that's really. The kudos from all over the whole to the place the in the in the conversation about marijuana which I'm all for I just want to know is either you can speak to the context. As you know metropolitan. Would necessarily give them or I don't know in the legislation and they are very. That's a halt and if we're thinking about your metaphor of expressway you know one of those it's one of the education particularly for our black and brown you to know that there's a certain. When you drive down Peachtree you end up in Brooklyn that's not it when you drive down south there where you're a little bit of a cock carriage and you drive down Decatur Street you end up in Decatur oftentimes we get that's not right and so those rules might not apply when it comes to the was a ship in that hit that it Alamance into a whole host of other problems for a young man or young woman of color who now because I fear a city where you they have weed on on in they're not going to get arrested it could just turn into a whole host of other things maybe some resistance so I just wonder particularly your organization the level of education. Is want to be in place for those to understand that if that legislation is passed that's more I mean that's not ELEANOR HALL. You know. Well you know the short answer is just that we've been doing it you know we've been out on the streets you start to hundreds and hundreds and hundreds of folks is directly in this and there's been a lot of news that hopefully tonight will be a lot more news coverage. Of this situation and I think that. You know that it's going to be really hard to get the word out I think it's on elected officials actually that housed Telic hold a town hall forum or a piece of you know do a town for him to let folks know when we talk to people at the get you know the metro Atlanta that it's true that that is true of many things in metro Atlanta counties a very different place right and usually just cross a line here and there but I think people actually we do kind of know you know when you're in for you know when you're in a you know and you know when you're when net and it ending up with you know actually what color you are your immigration status you you relate differently law enforcement in those places Sadly that's like the reality of many of our lives but so I think it's really. They were in to do the public education piece. But I think it's also important to then have the movement expand and go take it all the other city you know you don't have to get caught having to go city by city and so I think that we need to use each hadn't really as leverage for more you know and as leverage to the state level because they could just become life on the state level and then we would be you know in a much better position. And there was a struggle or so before this. For. All. I know. For all workers. We. Know this by. Still. I'll talk to you about that I've said over it because there was really not that a letter they get they don't make sure the little bit so I ran into a judge one day that this is actually a real story it sounds like a joke right I didn't get it today we're actually on a plane and she was lecturing me about how I need to take my research from up here and bring it down there. So I mean I thought OK OK I got to get it like no you need to say it like this OK but that was that's not the point she's a she was a judge in Florida and one of the things that she starts to do was when people would come in and they had their different plea bargain things she'd lined them up according to their actual crime that they committed and then have them flip over the actual pleas that they've been given and people start. Noticing that all this judge is doing this and so the public that the DA had to sort of the D.A.'s had to change their behavior at least within this courtroom because it was actually being very transparent about the actual plea bargains that people were actually being offered and that they were taking. So to me I mean I was amazed by her in spite of fact that she was kicking my butt on the run and you know everybody needs to be pushed and certain directions and so that's great too but transparency and more transparency in each stage of the process and even thinking about the ability to pill during the process because there are certain things that we know well one we know that every stage we see any qualities by race so shake not a set as gender. Typical things and we just sort of accept it but why should we accept it why can't we actually a pill things before the someone actually says I'm pleading guilty. Or can we actually after somebody please guilty because they've actually been denied the right to self incriminate themselves because you have to take a plea before you can actually get. An actual public defender to defend you so young to the in erthly has to be satisfying to whatever person you're playing to and typically this going to be guilty then you get the public defender and then they're like Why did plead guilty if you didn't do it. At that point so a very circular system that actually does not do what we believe. We are do in our rights. And particularly I would say just transparency and that they think it's really crucial is really crucial but also when we look at doing away with minimum that I think a lot of times people. Later on with those lower sentences specially for a minute color what we see is that they're basing it on their prior him so if your first aunt was possession which has a mandatory minimum that's already a record the judge did not have the opportunity to send it you to a diversionary program or a drug treatment program if you're a user you are ready treating as if you are friends as over to to distribute mandatory minimum because you and your friend were getting high with day so now your second time when the judge is more free they're like you already have you know you're no longer a first time offenders so that's what I believe that needs to be changed that's the transparency and so when you look back to the literature look at that what they are in the look at it from the sentencing for second third for the feds as versus first offense because the mandatory minimum messes up so many people and the first of it. And I think I just want to add something so I feel like it's a. It's a cause which is so in the juvenile justice world there was a long time where people there was a debate whether it was judge's discretion or right where it is it better as a judge's discretion whether you're going to transfer someone from June as a result or is it better this is a matter of law and I think what you come up with is you get your template racist outcomes either way and you and I feel like for me that's one thing that that drives me to feel like it's very important to get into the weeds of policy as we walk down a certain road but I think it's really important to be asking the question about whether this system is redeemable in this way at all because if you look at it you know a lot of people will say that's right it's not broken if it's doing exactly what it was designed to do and if we look at the history of it and ask what it was designed to do those disproportionate or disparate outcomes are exactly what it was designed to do so I just feel like there will be a lid that's actually going to make good examples of the limitations of tweaking like will say with no morning measure even to judge especially well just special and there could be a few good judges for sure and I could probably. Even that way if I had to choose one but we all know about current rights we all know about what happened so I think it's more of like making sure when the right yes the editing gates and it's in the form we're going to go big picture back and actually just like what if we kept sentences all sentences right but if we actually looked at things that were read that there was no credit for increased you know second time third time words and there's like different things that would I think more drastically change how we were looking at what the impact is so what we have our intent is to punish or if our intent is to make our community safer and maybe if we use that lens it leads us down to a whole set of policy things that have nothing to do with this right with this and now that there are at over here and when it's over for the sake of time we're going to have to wrap up but I do want to say before you all these are final status that I have learned at all and I hope that the others I like the first words they think Egypt are coming but if you could I know you gave us a lot of your insight but what is the one last piece of the site that you have been given this year that you like the crowd to go away with and the tell someone else I will start here and go on that because the actual in the presence of. God But. Pretty good the good of the so that we haven't talked coverage of three and so it will form and I guess he's hoping I'm going to go with the message but I'm going to I'm going to sort of play off what we've sort of thing so. You have a lot of power as citizens as students and you should use that power for good because the great power comes great responsibility Spiderman right all right. So in thinking about this OK it will what could we do how could we change things. Slow a famous famous writer I drew a lot. Or. You never can pronounce the last name but she said you can't dismantle the master's house with the master's tools. So we can try tweaking the master's house with the master's tools or we could actually think of this in a very completely different way and try to imagine in vision what does justice look like. What is our reason for fantasy and is it are we actually playing the piano I don't know it sounds like a piano is he back there sorry. And I guess the last thing I want to say is that. So in the end in a criminal investigation if it is found that. A police officer somebody along the way did something that was incorrect that led to the you know the visibility of other things that were criminal them we call it through the poison streets I'm sure if you've watched any kernel so he will say for the poisonous tree for the poisonous tree. Well we know very well that well OK most of us know at least by now since you've been listening you know not fall asleep or anything like that that. Our whole punishment system is built with the purpose of actually subjugate some populations and actually making successful economically. Through many forms of different path little other populations because when we actually take a person down that means that that person is out of the race and that means that other people get lifted up but if we can acknowledge that this is a system that has been going on for such a long time then it is a system that is a result and it is fruit of the poisonous tree it is just that and so we have to actually we're actually I think ethically we have to. Stop and go back and say well. What could things look like what should we look like what are our ethics what do we say we believe in versus what we have done because our Constitution doesn't align with what we've done nothing the lines of what we do and so what kind of people do we actually want to be versus what are the actual effects of what we've done. I would say. There should be opportunities for education in general and you should be asking and in prison setting why those opportunities are not there when you go back and as soon although you're not from here you go back to your stay is this something is available in federal system that's not available in all states as all the way up to college degrees as those used agrees or high school diploma if allowing people to get that while incarcerated would greatly increase their chances on the outside I would say that the second thing I would say is that would leave you guys with this this is an opportunity for leadership for each and every one of you each and every one of you can be a leader and as my mentor Dr David Satcher former president Morehouse School of Medicine It always said we need leaders who care enough who know enough but who are willing to do it now so you're here so you care you've heard something so I hope each of you choose the opportunity to know more now on sleds for all of you guys to go and do more you know be a little. I think. I really appreciate both things I think I had to leave with something it might be like slightly on a different note which is just so they also yes go be leader and get engaged and then also I'd like a lot of conversations today. And one of the questions around sort of buildings sympathy or something like that like I also don't want to leave folks especially I'm sure there are people here in this room who. Have loved ones MacArthur given a job themselves have been jailed it's like. To do with now the idea that folks are victims or to be wards of the leg but just to really recognize that there's a movement building power of forming press right people and probably on the can like this to be really great to have somebody who's been locked up for it I think I will speak directly from their period and we have family members of that here who've been talking so but it's just to like also so it's like yes take leadership in that way and also help support the leadership of folks who've been locked up in bed directly impacted by this isn't support that we're in transpose who are targeted constantly by the police. Who are organizing what's now the solutions I think you know get behind the organizing that's happening that's really been being led by folks who are like they've been through it they know what it really is and what it really is and see and are leading the charge. Yes. All right let's take our family. Unit Circle video from sales rebuttal question love.