But it is another one please join me in giving a warm go to take welcome to Catherine to thank you. Can you hear me. Thank you so much Aditya le for that very kind introduction and thank you all for having me here I'm very honored to be part of the impact series and although I'm admittedly a Tarheel as you heard I'm also very proud to say that my grandfather was a graduate of Georgia Tech and my uncle and as I thought about it. I really. Credit very much of my being in Atlanta and to my grandfather and Georgia Tech specifically he came here and was a graduate of the School of Architecture in one thousand nine hundred six moved here from Tennessee and long story short that brought all the family from other states and you know here we are today so we definitely grew up singing all the fight songs and going to the football games and I really appreciate my Georgia Tech roots in many ways. Where I have sought to make an impact is through the arena of real estate development and specifically I am passionate about creating lovable walkable sustainable communities that will make this city and very philosophically this world a better place and so. You know in conjunction with that and also as an entrepreneur I think I've been fascinated with how to combine and how to combine the pursuit of product innovation with what is otherwise a very old line capital intensive industry that is not necessarily known for its speed of. Change so that is one of the things I wanted to talk about today as part of my overall impact thoughts. Just in general. So that. When I think about creating value for real estate that sort of break it down simplistically in a couple of the the major food groups or real estate. And again I while I appreciate that not all of you are real estate developers nor heaven forbid would ever want to be a real estate developer we do share very much share a common City and I'm hoping that today I can share and offer some of my own ideas for how we can all make this a place and make our communities wherever they are places that we're very proud and excited to be part of. So in general on the real estate front you have your financial engineering approach your commoditization approach in creative place making and of course the lines get blurred and there are elements of each and all of the above but in general financial engineering often involves this sort of very sharp tool kit of financial instruments you know cap rates bread's and timing and tax strategies and a number of different instruments that can be used to add value but not necessarily a huge and heavy focus on the underlying product itself on the commoditization front you can see an example here you know I kind of think about it as sort of the Wal-Mart of real estate development where the focus is on a very streamlined efficient. Repetitive product where you are able to harvest wonderful cost efficiencies and. You know really take advantage of that repetition and then on the creative place making front you're really focused that strategy is focused on her. Value through this notion of uniqueness or product differentiation. Where the emphasis might be more on top line revenue use while also trying to balance and make sure you're smart about the costs but. It all has to be balanced out and of course the third strategy is obviously the one where I've chosen to focus my efforts. On the place making front. You know obviously with any of these strategies there are pros and cons and benefits and so forth but. Place making is a very complicated complex time consuming strategy and process but with that comes by definition high barriers to entry because the brain damage is not necessarily something that everyone wants to take on by the same token when you're able or when you engage in that level of complexity and sort of customization there are high expectations on the part of the customer and in a heavy level of engagement and as you work through that though and balance it out you're able to achieve a wonderful loyal Mr stickiness of the customer that goes along with that heavy level involvement. And finally as I touched on a minute ago one of the big challenges is managing costs because when you have a lot of repeated customization by definition you're not streamlining inefficient and so forth so you know really managing those costs is critical but ideally if you've done your job right you're able to outpace the market on the topline and really make the financial equation work out. So I thought I would go through a little bit of a how to guide which are some of the strategies that we've used over time that if worked well for us in really thinking through. You know what are the elements of creative place making and it starts really almost counter-intuitively just by listening and we come to a place or an opportunity or a site and start by thinking OK what is this what is this place what does it want to be what's its history what is it surrounded by what is it connected to physically what is it connected to socially you know who is the community that surround it what are their values. We want our communities to be real and authentic and one part of that is really looking at the history of that place and you know whether it's reusing some old building or even in one case with one project you know had beautiful historic trees that we were able to take forward but any of that historic fabric that we're able to incorporate just gives that much more richness and uniqueness that contributes to the authenticity of it being a real place. Another element of creative place making is challenging the rules and. It's really important if you're going to continue to innovate and and sort of create this uniqueness that you think critically about what are otherwise conventional rules so just to give an example in a prior chapter I worked with those properties and. Helped put together this is post Parkside it tent than Piedmont and post at the time was written as moving in town from a more of a Suburban History and you know we have these formulas you have to do at least two hundred units and you need a pool and a tennis court you know sort of a formula. And we found ourselves with a two acre site thinking OK we can't fit all this we can't do this. And what we really were able to drill down to was. You know at the end of the day it's about amenities and that's what all of this pooled and score in it this is that's what's the core and so we were able to rethink and say OK maybe we can do a misting station instead of a pool or here you can see in the foreground the entrance to Piedmont Park which was literally right next to the project you don't need your own tennis court you can you know people park as a tennis court and so forth and so on and so a lot of it is just getting to the essence of what the rule was intended to do and then rethinking another way to do it. It's really important with any of these strategies to align with the right kind of capital that supports the strategy and for creative place making one of the the best capital partners that we found is is patient equity capital and across multiple examples what we found is that. By definition a lot of times if you're working on creating new and different and unique places you need someone who's willing to take risks and also a partner who is willing to make an investment that may not make the quickest book the first day the first minute but will build a project that will stand the test of time and ultimately outpace the market sort of the tortoise and the hare concept that you're probably familiar with. But but that critter that capital and the sharing of values and strategies is so important to aligning interest as you're going into any of these projects. And a huge believer that great design is a major differentiator in any of these creative place making opportunities. I'm sure you've all studied cases and companies like Nike where. Great design is just integral to their strategy and I believe the same with our real estate developments it is worth every penny spending the extra money to team up with a great design group and I use the term design loosely and holistically because the design is not just about the architecture of the building but it's also about a you know a holistic approach that gets to the interiors of the building to the furniture to the branding to the signage to the street skate that's outside the building it all has to be thoughtful and integrated and consistently well designed otherwise there's not an integrity to the message that you're trying to send to the market. As you can imagine with this highly customized project or product it's all the more important to have the right fit with the customer and really understanding your customer is just a fundamental element of this strategy and really any kind of development. There are as you know huge forces at work you know between the middle millennia old and the baby boomers you have the two largest generational demographics in U.S. history and they're having a tremendous impact on real estate development. We happen to think that there's a nice alignment with those demographic trends because we find those two groups wanting a lot of the same thing swear rather than having the all the old people sent off to a retirement farm out in the suburbs or put in a tower away from everybody else they want to be part of the community just as anybody else does they want to go to the same restaurants that they've loved they want to be near their kids and their rank kids. Too. They all want to be connected to the beltline or you know places where they can walk instead of having to drive everywhere they go so we see a lot of these demographic trends reinforcing the kind of creative place making urban infill strategy that is really important to our work but again regardless. Of whether you're building a commodity product or whatever you know you have to understand the customer because it does no good to build a project if you don't have anybody to live there or populate the offices. I think another really important element is creating a sense of community and that's not just about the buildings but it it's really about the people and just as with the design topic that I mentioned a minute ago it's important to take a holistic approach to community and in creating community there are so many elements and pass to doing so whether it's through social media or the arrangement of the buildings or the proportion or the design having many mayors this is a woman here in name BIA who from the very beginning of this project became the one who knew everyone and sort of glued the people of the community together and I'm sure you all know whether it's in school or wherever you are there are these many mayor types and they're wonderful people that really bring community to their surroundings. Even food can be a huge source of community and a way to gather people and we used to joke that for our company. Food was to us as a real estate developer as golf is to a lot of other real estate development firms it was our way you know our gathering point. And finally it's critical with any of these projects I mentioned earlier they're they're very complicated. Very time consuming and you have to obsess over the details and in fact the details are really what I think is the most fun part it's it's the essence of what brings something to life and all of those details really add up to create that uniqueness this is Robert Davis who was the founder of Seaside in Florida and it's. Widely known that his wife was the person who really glued together the town center in Seaside if you ever had a chance to visit there. She was the one that worked meticulously with all of those individual retailers and helped them with their merchandising and their signage and their storefronts and. Really just fretted group by group to bring together what ultimately became the heart of the community and and really helped transform everything around it. I thought I would take some of these general concepts and just sort of walk through a case study about a project that we did to help illustrate maybe more specifically some of the things we're talking about this is a protocol Mixon which is located in North Charleston South Carolina and it's a great example of creative place making not just of building a new project but in this case really turning around a very difficult situation. What we started with basically was a failed project in a bad location when we were when we were brought into to the process. Mixon was basically eighteen homes which you'll see tiny little cluster here. Over about a forty acre side of undeveloped property this was a former public housing project and you can see the sort of the ghosts of the streets that were there from the old public housing project and all the buildings have been demolished. And and then on the right you can get a sense of how it was basically this sort of surreal place with eighteen homes out in a field and it was just sort of a ghost town Here's another view is sort of an eerie and eerie place at the time and. I think it had the additional challenge of being North Charleston not Charleston so you know not the historic district that we all think of when we think of Charleston but what I would graciously call an outer borough of Charleston up near the airport and there was just it was just in the middle of nowhere and people didn't have a reason to go there per se what that did was to really put an emphasis on our strategy in bringing people there and finding reasons to go there because they wouldn't otherwise be going to this location. So what did we do in you know starting out and just as I said earlier. Listening and thinking about the place we started just thinking about what is this community and connecting with Charleston itself and you know Charleston from our perspective was a city that was all about art and. Preservation and creativity and great food and so we set about with this notion of building Mixon around the themes of food and great design and community. And since there was nothing there no there there the first thing we did was to build community before we built the community and what I mean by that if you can see here was literally out in the middle of that green field that you saw we built a pole barn a very simple structure up in the corner here that became a place to host of events we had food truck. Radios and dog festivals and makers markets and craft fairs and. Just started creating reasons for people in that surrounding community to come there and just started learning helping them learn where this place was. And the about the way the verse I mentioned she was the in this specific project the one who has all these people came from North Charleston and parks or on all these other areas around us would start remembering their names and remember that they came to the dog Festival last week and now they're back to you know come by. Cutting board from the crafts person there. One of the other things we did very early on was to build a seven thousand square foot private bath and Racquet Club with a wonderful pool and dining and racket sports and this was intended along the same lines to be a way for people from all over the Charleston area to be members and to have a reason to come here but also of course serving the people on site in the mix and project itself so again another way to sort of retrain traffic patterns and foot patterns to bring people here and start to create a They're there. The club became a great place to host events and weddings and bar mitzvahs and different activities and. As part of the club we built a restaurant called Basak That was open to the public can join you know using the same kitchen basically which you can see here in this photo. And we were very excited we worked very hard on our P.R. and Southern Living road up boss ACOA is one of their favorite bars that they cover and. You know was helping really get the word out about you know bringing people to the site to come to the restaurant. In addition to the club there was just this general theme of creating a physical heart to the project and I showed you all those eight thousand homes that were. Built in the field well most of them weren't sold and so we we rented out whatever wasn't sold we put in as you can see in the upper left hand there retail spaces in the ground floors of some of the units where there otherwise would have been a garage and here for example mix and market was a wonderful gourmet coffee shop with great sandwiches that would cater to the military base nearby. I mentioned about Basak on the restaurant. We you know here's a flower shop in the base of another one of the units we had a hair salon. Nest was a little furniture store and you know we would host farmer's markets in temporary structures around this area and again the goal was to create this physical heart where you had momentum and energy from this common set of amenities. So you know it doesn't do any good to have all these amenities if there is no one there to use them and it was very important as the market started to pick back up again that we launched an initial development phase of two hundred sixty eight multifamily units called the flats Nixon and this was not only something that made sense from a market perspective as an investment but it was also a great way to bring people to the site going to the restaurant going to the coffee shop using the parks and so forth and you know really starting to generate some momentum and energy because we had a lot of land to sell and a lot of you know single family homes and so forth that needed to feel an energy moving in a momentum in on the site to really inspire a builder to want to buy land. I mention design earlier and Nixon everything about Nixon was had this consistent theme of great design the original homes had their own very Charlestonians design that you probably saw the club was very modern sleek design and then with the units the multifamily units we we really work through every aspect of the interior of the leasing office the branding. You can see the unit interiors and the courtyard we even have these wonderful common screen porches Here's the outside view of the screen porches that we're community gathering places in the apartments with our own you know branded thing pong table I mean we were going nuts on this design but really every detail as I said earlier it was so important to have that holistic approach down to the smallest of details to really communicate consistently this notion of quality and brand integrity. The other dimension of that that's really important was taking that great design out to the street so it wasn't just a community that sort of fed on itself but we worked hard on the surrounding streets and in the internal streets to to completely redo the streetscapes to be much more walkable and have what we call natural forms of traffic calming with bulb outs and medians and street trees and engaging the buildings to connect to the streets with stairs and stoops and steps that were places that people could sit in see their neighbor read the paper or what have you. And then the next chapter has become and it has work thankfully interest from the builder community as the single family market picked up you know catalyzing those land sales not every new home will be modern but it was. To us to show a range of styles and designs so it wasn't all just sort of Disney world all one look sort of all. Master coordinated. So what started two years ago is this sort of forty acre undeveloped site basically now looks like this. And ultimately is leading to a master plan as we continue to build out the project that has five hundred home that's a hundred fifty million dollar development with a mix of multifamily single family townhouse retail the amenities that we looked at. It's it has really been a wonderful opportunity to generate that momentum and I'm happy to share that the apartments for example. Exceeded the original underwriting by fifty percent in their rents and of outpace the whole sub market same thing with the single family homes so we're finding with these early indicators that the strategies working in the in the energy in the momentum are in fact coming coming through. I think just in general and in the last. Area I want to well I'm sorry I think. Just to kind of research it for mix and we have the sort of building a community the focus on great design throughout the project building the physical heart with amenities and common places for people to gather and then bringing people to the site through these vertical components like the multifamily development to create the energy and activity and that was in this particular case sort of the series of steps that we took to to really sort of jump start this project and. Hopefully give you some big. Examples of literally how we did that. So going forward you know where do we go with all this and what's going on with Atlanta. It's interesting it. We're finding in the market that the customer is demanding more and more and the customer wants all of that wonderful uniqueness and customization but they want all the low costs they want it all more for less and that in turn is you know really putting continued pressure on the development community to to find a way to bring all that together and I won't claim that we have all the answers but it literally just sort of takes a project by project very meticulous approach you know using every tool in the toolkit to get there. And by the same token. Companies really want their real estate to be an extension of their brand because that helps them attract the kinds of employees and creative workers that they want to have in their companies and people individuals want the places that they live to be an extension of their own personal brand and who they are and what they care about and what they love and so in general it's really important for the real estate development world too to reflect what's going on in the market and as you all know we're very much in the middle of this innovation economy and the innovation economy is all about you know the blurring of lines and so when it gets back to real estate you know is this office space or is this light manufacturing you know we we find office building lobbies that are starting to look like coffee shops or hotel lobbies and there's this just sort of general blurring of lines among in between the uses that I think I find fascinating and you see popping up all over the market. But by the same token we have to. In the developer we have to be flexible and nimble and adaptable to change just as the innovation economy is with all of its rapid prototyping and that's not always the easiest fit for as what I said before is the sort of old and capital intensive slow moving industry that's all that's infrastructure set up to move in years and decades as opposed to the nanoseconds of the innovation economy so it's a very interesting time for the development community to respond to what's going on with the realities of the market. And. And you know for Atlanta in general. It's I've never seen such an exciting time to be in the city the urban ism is alive it gives all of us energy. It's it's an incredibly dynamic city that's just getting better and better and richer and richer and that in turn as I'm sure you're seeing is a magnet bringing so many people to this city so many of you came here from other places excited by the energy that's Atlanta and again this is happening in so many other communities as well but I do worry a little bit in some ways about a certain sameness that I'm starting to see with sort of the development theme going on right now with all of this capital coming and and. What I you know my perspective is that we have an opportunity in Atlanta to create a city of places and great places and not just projects and that's going to take a lot of collaboration between public and private institutional an entrepreneurial. You know pulling from our history and focusing on the customer and all you know so many of the themes that I've talked about today and. You know you all and I you know we all have a part in shaping that city in the choices that we make whether it's how we spend our time or how we spend our money or even what we choose to do with our life's work and. My I guess and in general I would urge all of us to be very thoughtful and. And very deliberate about the choices that we make in making great choices so that we can shape the kind of city and the kind of communities and neighborhoods that we all will be proud of but I think most important of all it's because those those cities and communities have the ability to bring out the best in people and it's all about people at the end of the day so I will stop there happy to answer any questions and not appreciate your. Being here today thank you. And in the back. OK. I just wanted to start with getting an update about city markets and how that redevelopment is is going and how it got through the real estate. Slump in the city have that affected the great great question and just for clarity I I had the good fortune of working with Jamestown for a number of years and overseeing the development team that led that project I spun off our Green Street company that was sort of the in-house development team back in the fall so I do still of course stay in touch with my colleagues and so what I'll share is sort of through them. Parts of the market opened in the for. All the first phases were the residential with multi-family you know movements kind of occurring month to month and that's all been going really well the office space opened up with athenahealth and cartilage ICS and mailed him a number of the tenets that you might have seen in the press. The retail will be opening in phases so this spring for example there's a series of food hall tenants that will open and some of the sort of the first wave of that public food hall that will really be the heart and soul and gathering place for the public to come enjoy the project and then they'll be another wave in the fall of the sort of the balance of the retail. It was interesting with Potts we started that project in the in the bottom of the market you know it was a crazy leap of faith to buy a two million square foot into a building in the middle of you know just sort of covered up with barbed wire and fences and and. We found that the office space was the first to take off and ended up leasing about seventy five percent of what was about a half million square feet in just one year so it just sort of shot out of the gates and then the residential right behind it in the retail so we were deliberately just sort of rolling the phases as the market supports delivering those phases to the market but. The the project did not have a sort of cut the ribbon everybody runs them all grand opening it's been more of a sort of organic rolling opening so that's how it's it's it's sort of stepping through the phases. But I was wondering how did you how do you guys make the decision to take on a project like the market or like the mixing case today that you shared with others like like you said it's a giant leap of faith how do you guys what's your process for deciding to jump in. That's a it's a great question so just as a quick bit of history green. Property's was a company that had its origins with the Glenwood Park development in Grant Park East Atlanta area if you may be familiar with that. It was acquired by Jamestown private equity firm in two thousand and eight and Jamestown had this whole portfolio of broken deals that. Were development deals that they had done with twenty five or so developers all over the southeast and then the market just slammed the brakes on and so Jamestown needed an in-house development team to go methodically through this one point two billion dollars portfolio of projects or about twenty five of them and in each case reposition recapitalize restart So we had a lot of Nixon's sort of test you know how do we do this and. So it's a little bit of an unusual answer your question in that we as a team sort of inherited all of these deals and everything from Raul and to a ninety percent complete condo highrise in Brooklyn that had just stopped and ran out of money and was full of liens. And really just sort of had to think creatively and holistically about how to attack each case by case so going forward as I mentioned you know spinning Greenstreet off now that that portfolio is often study footing. It's much more starting with a clean slate about a fresh opportunity that you know isn't a place that we just choose. As opposed to sort of starting with that portfolio if that makes sense. What do you think is the greatest challenge to the current projects that are coming up inside the city of Atlanta. I think the biggest Well there are lot of challenges I think. What I'm saying is that land prices continue. Go up and up and up and you know as sellers see the market recover and see projects built they want to get the same thing for their land as the person down the street just got and so with those higher land prices there's a lot of pressure to build a lot of density and I think it's important to be able to absorb all that product. And so sometimes you sort of get in this spiral of having to build enough to support the land price or justify the land price you pay but it may or may not be. Enough or it may not be the right amount of product that the market really can support and absorb so I worry a little bit about all of this land driving this sort of capacity question. I you know you talked about how you're worried about Atlanta having a lot of sameness when it comes to development and I was at another panel discussion that talked about how Atlanta's got to the point where they can leverage opportunities so when developers come in because so many people want to build here you know they can gonna. Customize it where they can make sure that the development is is influencing the community so how would you recommend developers coming in and working with the community where that uniqueness shows with the development so it's not all the same his but it's a representation of the people that live there. I don't have a silver bullet answer maybe just some ideas. It's interesting from the development side. It's amazing how much influence the community has through the zoning process and Atlanta is built as many of you know on this N.P. you neighborhood planning unit. Process where you know adjoining neighborhoods and you sort of go on up to broader groups affect. But they get so involved in commenting on the look and feel of a project it's pretty interesting and I've been a part of a number of projects where a lot of it was very perscribe you know you have to have. X. the square footage of Windows or you know it I think through zoning and through even the community approach or the you know planning department approval in the city of Atlanta they have a lot of influence and so for those developers who may need a little bit more of a nudge in that area I think there is an opportunity for the community and for the city to have an imprint and and that's why I think you know my appeal to everyone is that you have more of a voice and you know through different channels where you can have that communication if you live here or even in other cities of course. At the end I All right so as we're looking forward into the next say three to five years I have a two part question so the first is which markets in communities and neighborhoods are you looking to target within those next two years in Atlanta and the second part is what are the sort of defining characteristics of those neighborhoods that you look for when you're starting a new project. Well going forward. Our particular focus has actually gone into a strategy that we call urban acupuncture where. We feel that by you know projects as small as you know one or two acres even you can go into a wonderful historic neighborhood put in what I think of as sort of micro mixed use but have this transformative impact on everything around it and. We're not necessarily focused on highrise you know Peachtree spine for example we're focused on neighborhoods like poncey Highlands and in the park. You know a fourth ward even on the west side you know areas where there's sort of medium density two to five stories very walkable an existing mix of uses so that we can have mixed use but we don't have to build it ourselves we can go in with residential and street retail but then maybe we're next to the beltline or we're next to an office existing office or single family neighborhood so it's important that our target neighborhoods have a fine grain mix of uses already but but we want to come in at that sort of main and main intersection of the neighborhood and and put in a great little gathering place that brings it all together. You already gave us a few examples of being projects you've done Atlanta but are there any others that you could give us more information about maybe future or current or past. So. Just in terms of some examples maybe you're OK so. I. Mentioned Glenwood park which was a. Wonderful opportunity we were teamed up at the time with Charles Brewer who is the founder mine spring who was a great example that patient equity capital and started that project in two thousand and one was a twenty eight acre site hundred twenty million dollars project but we were able to it was very early for sustainability so we were able to incubate a lot of sustainability technologies and experiment and sort of do some out of the box. Testing a product because we were all equity funded and Charles was a wonderful entrepreneur with that sort of value set. So that project has just recently sort of sold its final phases but was a great opportunity for walkability and sustainability in a. Going back in my post properties chapter I oversaw the team that built the post Riverside pride. Picked that was interesting I was in the mid ninety's and. We brought. Planning firm called D.V.C. to Atlanta which was very and this whole notion of New Urbanism was a brand new thing and. So we were trying there are some new planning concepts that were very much against the grain of the sort of standard suburban code which was what that Lana still have from the sixty's so we had to really sort of struggle with that and change street dimensions in architecture and. So you know each one has been its own different set of experimenting and trying to innovate but push the envelope on the existing codes that were in place and that takes definitely out of patience. But thankfully over time I think with some finished product to point to people you know we've had the chance to build up trust so when we go talk to the city they know that that experiment is probably a good ones to make and so. You out of that answer your question. I think. You've talked a lot about sort of the portfolios that you know you did and I was curious about Brooklyn and project and if there were any unique lessons learned there and also just if you've done other work in New York that you can share. Gosh Brooklyn. That was a highrise condominium project called the skirmish horn and. It was just. A buff a of of challenges and opportunities everything from. Flooding to. Construction leans to permit in challenges to repositioning and remarketing what was a failed project because it just literally had just stopped ninety percent complete just stopped. It we were able to restart it and clean it up legally and restart the construction finished the units we sold them all it ended up thankfully being the highest or the the best selling condominium project in New York in two thousand and ten and. I think in terms of lessons learned. It was just we just had to be very thorough because there were so many different issues we just had to literally like and a tangle use had to go one by one and pick each one apart and very methodically track everything and chase it down and there were no shortcuts. Jamestown our prior owner has is headquartered here in Atlanta but has an office in New York so Jameson has all sorts of projects in New York that are properties like Chelsea Market our own and existing assets but in terms of sort of ground up development we haven't or we didn't do any other work there besides the current one project. I think it's going to take for the entire mix and master plan to be built. It's a great question I think if this point it's driven largely by the pace of absorption of the single family homes. I would you know. I would guess another five years realistically. Just because it's North Charleston and you know there's only so much product that that submarket can absorb. Glenwood park just as another datapoint took thirteen years from start to finish. But it went through two downturns in the market so you know who's to say with a healthy upswing maybe mix and can go faster but that you know those mass those master developments they just take a long time there's a lot there to absorb sort of back to the question a little bit earlier. I think it's important to be realistic about how fast the market can absorb a project and it's only going to go as fast as it will go. Sustainability I have a question the effect is do you keep in mind when you're running a development for example if you are planning away from the center of the city most of the people have to come into the city for their jobs and the traffic issues are already getting you know problematic in US So how do you foresee that because if you know if if more developments are being made just outside the city although in the Sedona of the city where I was late did a lot of high rise buildings abandoned buildings in the downtown which could be you know good wood introduced into a small community so how do you factor in all those traffic problems I know this is the inability to use. Well going forward our focus is really urban infill so we wouldn't you know we're not pursuing Greenfield locations like you know out from the city and you know I guess our philosophy is that the most inherently sustainable thing you can do is to reuse existing infrastructure you know the city and its taxpayers have built all the sewers and all the roads and all the transit systems and all the you know physical and and you know soft infrastructure to support people and if you can go in and leverage that that's inherently sustainable just as you know New York is one of the quote Rina cities in the world which is very counterintuitive but it's just incredibly efficient because it's walkable and connected so. That at a very high level is is our philosophy about sustainability because the first thing you can do to make a sustainable choice is to pick a location that's. Efficient from that infrastructure perspective and then you go. And of the sticks and bricks and the water fish you know all the details but you got to start with getting the right location. I have one more last question in the couple a couple questions had touched on. How long the mixin developments going to take in and that you had talked about how you need to be patient just the question of the students who may want to get into are interested in real estate as a profession what kind of characteristics and traits do you think have made you successful in your role and what do you think that they should bring to the industry both the challenges that or or what has made people successful in the past but also the challenges that the industry is facing now for to morrow. That's a great question. I guess the way I describe the real estate a real estate career or profession is that you have to be the consummate generalist you have to know about this incredible breadth of topics from politics to finance to property management to sales to design construction engineer I mean it's just everything and then you know maybe it's only a few inches deep but you've got to know enough to bring together and lead a team that each of whose members are expert in those different topics and yet the other challenge is that any one moment you have to go down into the weeds so you know we go and have to match the key with the numbers on the mailboxes I mean literally little details all the way up to high level strategy of you know market positioning and customer perception you know so it's this sort of broad Parys Onil and deep vertical and you have to it is just a really multi-dimensional career in terms of getting into it. There is no one perfect way. I find a lot of times people will come in through one of the vertical areas like construction or through design or finance. I happen to think it's really important no matter which channel you come through to really understand and be grounded in the financial because it's so critical to being able to be profitable because no one will ever imitate you or or or you know create a better place for more of these projects occurring if you're not financially successful so I think whether through graduate school or undergrad or or wherever you learn it through your training as an analyst to really be sharp with the numbers is a really important tool to have in the toolkit but otherwise you know there's just so many different channels you can come in and then ultimately sort of have that broader exposure. And a lot of it is just learning by doing which is how I had to do it and. Thank you very much for coming to church and thank you very much thank you thank you.